The clay-and-fire comparison does not describe the physical composition of the human heart, nor does it prove that ablution literally changes cardiac tissue. The strongest reading is moral and spiritual: the Quran uses familiar materials to depict humility, hardness, temptation, and receptivity to guidance.
What the objection gets right
The objection is fair if the passage is presented as a hidden lesson in anatomy or as proof that sin turns the heart into a clay-like substance, while water from ablution physically softens it. Clay is not a normal component of the heart, Satan's being created from fire does not make human sin chemically fiery, and washing the limbs does not provide a demonstrated medical mechanism for changing the heart's tissue.
That argument exposes a real error: treating every image in scripture as a scientific statement. The Quran does not say that human hearts are literally made of clay, that Satan's fire transfers into them, or that ablution hydraulically softens them. Those claims go beyond the texts.
What the Quran actually says
He said, "What prevented you from prostrating when I commanded you?" He said, "I am better than him. You created me from fire and created him from clay."
Quran 7:12
This verse concerns Satan's pride and his argument for refusing God's command. Fire and clay function here within the account of creation and as the basis of Satan's arrogant comparison. It does not say that human moral failure produces a physical change from clay to stone or fire.
Then your hearts became hardened after that, being like stones or even harder. For indeed, from stones are rivers that gush forth; and among them are those that split open and water comes out; and among them are those that fall down for fear of Allah.
Quran 2:74
The language itself is a comparison: hearts are "like stones," and even stones are portrayed as more responsive than some human beings. Classical commentators understood this as hardness of heart - resistance to truth, repentance, and awe of God - not as a claim about cardiac anatomy. The contrast with water is part of the imagery: stone can split and release water, while a spiritually hardened person may remain unmoved by signs and reminders.
What this does and does not establish
Ablution is a physical act with spiritual meaning. Authentic teachings describe it as a means by which sins are forgiven, but that does not require claiming that water physically softens the heart. The believer's "softening" is better understood as purification, remembrance, repentance, and renewed readiness to obey.
So the objection successfully rejects an exaggerated scientific-miracle argument. It does not refute the Quran's actual use of metaphor, because metaphor is not pretending to be anatomy. These verses establish a morally coherent picture of pride and spiritual hardness; they do not, by themselves, establish a modern scientific discovery about the human heart.