The argument correctly sees that the Islamic Mahdi and the Jewish Davidic Messiah are described through different genealogies and roles. But it does not establish that the Mahdi is meant to be the Jewish Messiah, still less that he is the Antichrist; Islamic sources distinguish all three figures.

What the argument gets right

The strongest form of the objection is straightforward. In Jewish expectation, the Messiah is a human king descended from David through the Israelite line. The Islamic Mahdi, by contrast, is an Arab leader from the family of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), traditionally understood as a descendant of Fatimah. If these genealogical requirements are taken seriously, one person cannot naturally satisfy both descriptions.

The objection also correctly observes that Muslims do not identify the Mahdi as the Messiah. The Quran explicitly calls Jesus the Messiah:

"The Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, was only a messenger of Allah and His word which He cast to Mary and a spirit from Him."

Quran 4:171

Thus, a man who claimed to be the Messiah in the sense of replacing or competing with Jesus would be contradicting a central Islamic belief, not expressing ordinary Islamic doctrine.

What Islamic sources actually teach

The Mahdi is a rightly guided ruler who appears before the final events. He is not described in the Quran as the Messiah, and the reliable hadith do not make him the Antichrist. In Islamic terminology, the Antichrist is al-Masih al-Dajjal, a deceiving claimant whose appearance is opposed by Jesus.

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) also described Jesus' return while referring to another leader already present:

"How will you be when the son of Mary descends among you and your imam is from among you?"

Sahih al-Bukhari; Sahih Muslim

Mainstream classical interpretation understands "your imam" here as the Mahdi or the Muslim leader at that time, while Jesus remains the Messiah. The two figures are therefore distinct, although they appear in the same eschatological period.

Hadith in Sunan Abi Dawud and other collections describe the Mahdi as being from the Prophet's family, and reports concerning the Mahdi were accepted by many major hadith scholars. Details about his name, genealogy, and chronology have varying degrees of strength, so one should not build a precise theory on every popular narration.

What this argument does and does not establish

It does establish a genuine difficulty for anyone claiming that the Islamic Mahdi is literally the Jewish Davidic Messiah. The genealogies and religious meanings do not match. It also exposes a common error: treating "messiah" as though it referred to one identical figure in every tradition.

It does not show that the Mahdi is the Dajjal. That conclusion has no sound Islamic basis. Nor does it refute the Islamic account of the end times, because Islam never requires the Mahdi to fulfil the Jewish definition of a Davidic Messiah. The apparent contradiction arises only when distinct titles and figures are combined into one person.