The argument is strong only if Islam teaches that Jesus personally performs God's final judgment of every human being. It does not. In Islamic teaching, Allah alone gives the final judgment, while Jesus (PBUH), when he returns, will rule justly in this world by revealed guidance.

Why the objection seems compelling

The objection can be stated in its strongest form. Islamic sources describe Jesus as a human messenger, not God. Yet they also describe his return near the end of time and portray him as a just ruler. If "judge" means examining every person's private motives, subconscious intentions, and concealed actions, then a created human being could not do this independently. That kind of complete knowledge and presence belongs to Allah alone.

This is a genuine difficulty for any claim that Jesus will be the omniscient judge of all humanity. But that is not the claim made by the Quran or the authentic reports.

Who performs the final judgment?

The Quran repeatedly assigns ultimate judgment to Allah, not to Jesus or any other prophet:

"Say: O Allah, Creator of the heavens and the earth, Knower of the unseen and the seen, You will judge between Your servants concerning that over which they used to differ."

Quran 39:46

Allah's knowledge is unique:

"With Him are the keys of the unseen; no one knows them except Him. He knows what is in the land and sea. No leaf falls but that He knows it."

Quran 6:59

Jesus himself is presented as a servant who does not claim independent knowledge of what people concealed after his departure:

"I only said to them what You commanded me: Worship Allah, my Lord and your Lord. And I was a witness over them as long as I remained among them; but when You took me, You were the Watcher over them."

Quran 5:117

What Jesus will do when he returns

The authentic hadith describe Jesus as a just ruler, not as the divine assessor of every heart. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said:

"How will you be when the son of Mary descends among you and your imam is one of you?"

Sahih al-Bukhari; Sahih Muslim

Classical scholars explain his role as public governance: he will restore justice, reject false religious claims about himself, and rule according to God's revelation. A human judge can judge outward cases through testimony and evidence without possessing omniscience. Hidden intentions remain with Allah, and the final accounting remains His.

What the argument does and does not establish

The objection successfully shows that Jesus cannot be both a merely created man and an independently omniscient final judge. Islam agrees with that conclusion. It does not show a contradiction in Islam, because Islam never gives Jesus that divine function. It instead exposes a category mistake: confusing Jesus' temporary, delegated earthly authority with Allah's universal and final judgment.

Thus the Islamic Jesus is finite, dependent, and honored as a prophet. His return magnifies Allah's justice; it does not turn Jesus into God.