Only God Can Forgive Sins, Yet Jesus Forgives Them
The argument from Mark 2 is one of the more serious Gospel arguments for the deity of Jesus. It should not be dismissed as though it were a mere misunderstanding by hostile scribes. In Mark 2:5 Jesus says to the paralytic, "Son, thy sins be forgiven thee." The scribes respond, "Why doth this man thus speak blasphemies? who can forgive sins but God only?" (Mark 2:7). Jesus then heals the man publicly "that ye may know that the Son of man hath power on earth to forgive sins" (Mark 2:10; compare Matthew 9:6; Luke 5:24). On a traditional Christian reading, Jesus does not correct the scribes' theological premise. He vindicates his authority by a miracle. Therefore, it is argued, Jesus is doing what only God can do.
That is the argument at its strongest. It has real force. The scribes are not objecting to ordinary interpersonal forgiveness, as when one human being forgives another for a wrong done directly to him. They are reacting to Jesus' pronouncement over the man's sins in the presence of God. In the Hebrew Bible, sin is ultimately against God, and atonement and remission belong to God's prerogative. When Jesus declares the paralytic forgiven without referring him to the temple, sacrifice, priesthood, or an explicit prophetic formula such as "Thus says the Lord," the scribes' alarm is understandable. Many Christian interpreters, from patristic writers to modern scholars such as R. T. France and Larry Hurtado, have seen here a significant christological claim: Jesus acts in a sphere belonging to God.
What the Text Actually Says
The key question, however, is whether Mark 2 requires the conclusion that Jesus is personally identical with God, or whether it presents him as exercising authority to pronounce and enact forgiveness on God's behalf. The episode clearly presents Jesus as possessing authority to forgive, but it does not spell out whether that authority is delegated, intrinsic, or both. Its wording therefore does not by itself settle the later metaphysical question of Jesus' identity. Mark's narrative nevertheless gives the claim unusual weight: Jesus pronounces forgiveness directly, and the healing is offered as public confirmation that the Son of Man really has this authority.
"But that ye may know that the Son of man hath power on earth to forgive sins, he saith to the sick of the palsy, I say unto thee, Arise..." (Mark 2:10-11)
The word translated "power" in the King James Version is Greek exousia, a broad term that can denote authority, right, freedom, or power. It does not function as a technical term meaning either "delegated authority" or "non-divine status." Jesus' answer is indeed authority-language rather than an explicit sentence of identity such as "I am God," but the lexical choice alone cannot determine whether the authority is received, inherent, or uniquely shared. Context and the wider Gospel must do that work.
Matthew's version makes this even clearer in its concluding line:
"But when the multitudes saw it, they marvelled, and glorified God, which had given such power unto men." (Matthew 9:8)
Again the term is exousia, and the Greek says that God gave "such authority" (exousia toiautēn) "to human beings" (tois anthrōpois). Matthew plainly foregrounds God as the giver. Yet this is not a straightforward denial of Jesus' deity: the plural may be a generic way of speaking about human agents or may widen the implication of Jesus' ministry, and Matthew elsewhere gives Jesus an exceptionally high status, especially in Matthew 28:17-20. The verse therefore supports bestowed authority in this narrative, but it cannot by itself resolve the relation between that authority and Matthew's wider christology.
The Strongest Christian Reply
A careful defender of the traditional doctrine will reply that delegated authority does not exclude deity. In Trinitarian theology, the Son receives from the Father without being a mere creature. John's Gospel, for example, can say both exalted and subordinate things about Jesus. The Father gives life to the Son, yet the Son gives life to whom he will (John 5:21, 26). The Father gives judgment to the Son, yet all are to honor the Son as they honor the Father (John 5:22-23). Therefore, the fact that authority is "given" does not automatically disprove the deity of Christ.
This is an important reply. Christian orthodoxy has never claimed that the Son is the Father. It can accommodate language of mission, sending, and giving. John 5:26-27 says:
"For as the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself; and hath given him authority to execute judgment also, because he is the Son of man."
For Nicene theology, this is compatible with eternal generation and the economic mission of the Son. The Father gives; the Son receives; yet the Son shares divine life. Thus, an argument against a simplistic "Jesus receives authority, therefore he cannot be divine" would be too quick.
Still, this does not mean that Mark 2, read in isolation, states the Nicene doctrine. The passage presents Jesus as having authority on earth to forgive sins, but Mark does not explicitly say in this scene that the Father granted it; that attribution is made more directly in Matthew 9:8 and fits the broader New Testament pattern. Nor does Mark explain the metaphysical basis of Jesus' authority. A Trinitarian reading is compatible with the passage, especially within the Gospel's wider and canonical context, but "authority" should not be translated into "delegated and therefore non-divine." The immediate narrative establishes extraordinary authority and vindicates it; whether that authority belongs to Jesus as divine Son must be argued cumulatively.
Forgiveness by God and Forgiveness Through Agents
The scribes' statement, "Who can forgive sins but God only?" is true in an ultimate sense. All sin, finally, is answerable to God. But the Bible also contains forms of forgiveness mediated through human beings. This does not make those human beings God.
In Genesis 50:17, Joseph's brothers ask him:
"Forgive, I pray thee now, the trespass of thy brethren, and their sin; for they did unto thee evil."
Joseph is asked to release offenders from a wrong done against him; the Hebrew terms can describe interpersonal forgiveness, not necessarily God's judicial remission. This is a genuine but limited analogue. It does not by itself explain Jesus' public pronouncement over a man whose sin against Jesus is not narrated. Likewise, Paul commands Christians:
"Forbearing one another, and forgiving one another... even as Christ forgave you, so also do ye." (Colossians 3:13)
Human forgiveness is commanded as imitation of divine or Christlike forgiveness. Again, this does not reduce Mark 2 to ordinary interpersonal reconciliation. The paralytic has not wronged Jesus in any obvious narrative sense. Jesus is pronouncing forgiveness before God. That is why the scene is so weighty. But the wider biblical usage warns against an absolute syllogism: "Forgiveness of sins occurs; only God in every sense can forgive sins; therefore the forgiver must be God." Scripture itself is more nuanced.
John 20 and Delegated Remission
John 20:23 is especially relevant:
"Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained."
Here the risen Jesus gives his disciples authority related to the remission and retention of sins. Christian traditions interpret this differently. Roman Catholic and Orthodox theology often connect it with ecclesial and sacramental authority. Many Protestants understand it as the church's authority to proclaim the gospel, declaring forgiveness to those who repent and warning the unrepentant. In either case, the text gives human agents a real role in the administration or declaration of forgiveness.
This matters because if Mark 2 meant that any exercise of forgiveness-language over sin is by definition an act only a divine person can perform, John 20:23 would become difficult to explain. The disciples are not thereby made divine; their authority is explicitly derivative of Jesus' commission. That analogy is suggestive, but it should not be pressed into an exact equation: John 20 explicitly records Jesus sending the disciples, whereas Mark 2 does not explicitly state in the scene who granted Jesus this authority. The wider New Testament presents Jesus as sent by the Father, but the source and metaphysical status of his authority remain distinct questions.
The strongest Christian distinction is that the disciples forgive ministerially, while Jesus acts with an authority the story treats as extraordinary. That distinction has merit, but the grammar should not be overstated. In Mark 2:5, aphientai ("are forgiven") is a present passive form and can be read as a "divine passive," with God understood as the unmentioned agent; it can also function in context as Jesus' authoritative declaration. The Greek form alone does not decide between those readings. In either case, Jesus deliberately makes the pronouncement and then claims the Son of Man's authority to forgive, so John 20:23 does not erase the distinctive force of Mark 2.
But it does show that the New Testament can speak of forgiveness being announced or administered through authorized representatives. That observation blocks a bare rule that every human use of forgiveness language entails divine identity; it does not, however, make the disciples' commission equivalent to Jesus' action in Mark 2. The argument must therefore be stated carefully: Jesus' direct and effective pronouncement is extraordinary and may imply unique divine status in the Gospel's broader christology, but the mere occurrence of the verb "forgive" does not by itself establish ontological deity.
The Son of Man and Authority on Earth
Jesus identifies himself in this episode as "the Son of Man." The phrase can be an ordinary reference to a human being, but in some contexts it evokes Daniel 7, where "one like a son of man" approaches the Ancient of Days and receives dominion. Whether Mark 2 specifically invokes that vision is debated; the expression should not automatically be treated as a Danielic title. If the allusion is intended, it supports an exalted christological reading, but the figure's received dominion does not by itself prove either creaturehood or deity. It describes the authority granted in the vision, not the whole metaphysical status of the recipient.
Mark 2 can be read in light of that pattern: Jesus embodies God's reign by healing, restoring, and declaring sins forgiven. Yet the wording "has authority on earth" does not specify whether the authority is delegated, intrinsic, or both, and Mark 2 does not explicitly identify its giver in the scene. Thus a Danielic reading can support a high christology, but neither the phrase "Son of Man" nor the word exousia alone settles the question of Jesus' ontological identity.
What the Argument Establishes
Mark 2 is strong evidence that Jesus saw himself, and was presented by the evangelists, as more than a conventional teacher or prophet. He speaks with direct authority over sin. The scribes recognize that such authority belongs ultimately to God. Jesus does not retreat from the claim; he vindicates it by healing the paralytic. A low view of Jesus that makes him merely a moral instructor does not do justice to the passage.
But the passage does not, by itself, prove the full doctrine of Jesus' deity. Jesus' own explanation is framed in terms of exousia, authority. Matthew's conclusion says God had given such authority. John 5:26-27 explicitly says the Father "hath given" the Son life and authority to judge. John 20:23 extends remission and retention of sins to the disciples in a derivative way. Genesis 50:17 and Colossians 3:13 show that biblical forgiveness-language is not restricted to God in every respect.
The best conclusion is measured. Mark 2 is strong evidence that Jesus is presented as exercising an extraordinary authority over sin, and it is compatible with, though not by itself a full proof of, Trinitarian christology. The passage's exousia wording and Matthew's statement that God gives authority support an agency reading, but they do not rule out deity. Conversely, the traditional case should not be understated: John 20:28 directly has Thomas address the risen Jesus as "My Lord and my God"; Titus 2:13 is widely read as calling Jesus "our great God and Savior"; Hebrews 1:8 applies "God" to the Son in the traditional reading of Psalm 45, though the translation is debated; and Romans 9:5 is syntactically and punctuationally disputed but is read by many modern translations as calling Christ "God over all." Those passages require their own interpretation, but they show why Mark 2 should be assessed within the broader christological argument. Therefore, "Only God can forgive sins; Jesus forgives sins; therefore Jesus is God" captures a serious Christian inference, not a self-sufficient proof. Whether Jesus' authority implies ontological deity must be argued cumulatively from the New Testament, not from Mark 2:7 alone.