Discussions
Articles in the Discussions section.
- Does "Extraordinary Claims Require Extraordinary Evidence" Survive Its Own Test?
- Can "Only Science Gives Knowledge" Be Established Scientifically?
- Seven Theories of Knowledge, Each Judged by Its Own Standard
- Faith is not a valid route to truth, because it can be used to justify any proposition, including mutually exclusive ones
- The problem of hell and proportionality challenges theism
- Foreknown creation makes God morally responsible for the Fall
- The evil-God challenge undermines theism
- Pascal’s wager does not rationally justify belief
- Divine testing is incompatible with complete foreknowledge
- Presuppositional arguments assume what they are trying to prove
- Failed biblical prophecies undermine prophetic authority
- When Is Absence of Evidence Evidence of Absence?
- Is Demanding Empirical Evidence of God a Category Mistake?
- Empirical, Logical, Testimonial: Which Kind of Evidence Fits Which Kind of Claim?
- Religious Belief and Wellbeing: What Correlation Can and Cannot Show
- The burden of proof lies with the theist, and absent positive evidence the rational default is non-belief
- Petitionary prayer produces no result beyond what chance and ordinary causes already predict, which is what we would expect if no one is listening
- Cumulative natural selection fully explains the apparent design of living things, so the design argument gives no reason to posit a designer
- Religious belief is overwhelmingly predicted by birthplace, not evidence, so no believer is entitled to the confidence they place in their own tradition
- The instinct to call on God under mortal terror is not evidence that God exists
- Religious experience does not establish that God exists
- Fine-tuning probabilities cannot be established from a single observed universe
- Divine hiddenness and evidential silence
- A designed universe is challenged by cosmic hostility and human insignificance
- The universe is indifferent rather than providential
- Equal disaster mortality is evidence against supernatural protection
- A miraculous event does not by itself establish theism
- The Bible cannot prove its own divine authority merely by quoting itself
- Jesus may have originated as a myth rather than a historical person
- The resurrection lacks sufficient historical evidence
- Religious belief may be a human strategy for social control
- Theism is an excessively specific hypothesis with a low prior probability
- Divine simultaneity conflicts with the reality of temporal succession
- Messianic prophecies are retrofitted through allegory
- Heaven and hell may be products of human imagination rather than real supernatural realms
- Metaphysical essences are unsupported by empirical evidence
- The Slide From Methodological to Philosophical Naturalism
- God of the Gaps, and Naturalism of the Gaps
- What Physics Has Not Settled, and What That Does and Does Not Show
- Religion is fully explained as a natural human phenomenon, so no God is needed to account for it — and documented borrowing from earlier cultures undercuts any claim of unique divine revelation
- No testimony can rationally establish a miracle, because it is always more probable that the witnesses are mistaken or lying than that a law of nature was suspended
- Causation is not a fundamental feature of reality, so cosmological arguments rest on a folk notion mature physics has discarded
- Mind and purpose should not be projected onto ultimate reality
- Theism lacks a clear symmetry-breaker
- Quantum events challenge the principle that everything that begins has a cause
- Extreme harmful desires are better explained by physical brain differences than by universal human depravity
- An impersonal wave function can replace a divine foundation
- Abiogenesis: What Has Actually Been Demonstrated
- What Evolution Explains, and What It Does Not Claim To
- Does the Multiverse Answer Fine-Tuning?
- Genuinely novel properties emerge from matter, refuting the principle that a cause cannot give what it lacks
- God has always been an explanatory placeholder for what science had not yet explained, and that gap has only ever shrunk
- Human intuitions cannot reliably settle ultimate questions
- Why Consciousness Remains Hard for Materialism
- If Minds Evolved for Survival, Why Trust Them About Metaphysics?
- What Do Near-Death Experiences Establish?
- Has Materialism Collapsed?
- Consciousness need not be immaterial
- Death is the permanent cessation of biological function
- Can Moral Facts Be Objective Without a Grounding?
- Does the Problem of Evil Assume What It Denies?
- Grounding morality in God's commands makes right reduce to might, so theism does not secure objective morality and can sanctify atrocity
- A revealed text's science and morality track exactly what its human authors of that era would have known and believed, which is strong evidence of human rather than divine authorship
- Morality is socially constructed or relative to goals
- Dissolving moral criticism may make divine goodness empty
- An alleged divine message is not credible when its transmission is historically unreliable
- Religious belief is especially dangerous because supernatural accountability can override worldly ethics
- Nihilism challenges whether life has objective meaning
- The necessity of morality cannot prove God's existence
- Biblical commands and actions make the Christian God morally indefensible
- Determinism and the Responsibility Naturalists Still Assert
- An omniscient God who infallibly knows the future is incompatible with human free will and just accountability
- An omnipotent, loving God could create beings without free will
- Eternal hell undermines meaningful free will and moral transformation
- Is Naturalism Really the Simpler Explanation?
- The Stone Paradox and What Omnipotence Means
- Do Contradictory Religions Cancel Each Other Out?
- Necessary Existence: From Ibn Sina to Contemporary Modal Arguments
- The universe (or the totality of contingent things) can be an unexplained brute fact, so cosmological and contingency arguments give no reason to posit God
- An actual infinite causal regress is metaphysically possible, so there is no need for an uncaused first cause
- The concept of God is too ill-defined or incoherent to name a real object, so 'God exists' asserts nothing that could be true
- Cosmological and contingency arguments commit the fallacy of composition
- Once every member of the series is explained, the whole series needs no further explanation
- The principle of sufficient reason collapses all contingency into necessity, so it should be rejected
- A perfectly self-sufficient God would have no reason or need to create, so the act of creation is either evidence of need or is arbitrary
- The vast quantity of apparently gratuitous suffering — especially of innocent children — is strong evidence against an omnipotent, omniscient, wholly good God
- Metaphysical dependence need not bottom out in an ultimate ground, so grounding-based contingency arguments fail
- We never observe necessary causal connection, so the causal premise of cosmological arguments is unwarranted
- De re necessity is unintelligible, so arguments turning on a 'necessary being' rest on a confused notion
- The Bible’s depiction of God conflicts with the claim that he is all-loving
- Existence is not a property that can be added to a concept
- Intrinsic value independent of consciousness is incoherent
- Internal biblical contradictions undermine confidence in divine inerrancy
- Skeptical theism threatens ordinary moral reasoning and theistic expectations
- Inherited suffering challenges divine goodness
- The problem of divine justice from unclear revelation
- Meaning may be something humans create rather than discover
- Natural causes make a supernatural devil unnecessary
- Religious interpretation is often insulated from disconfirmation
- An omnipotent God needing rest is conceptually incoherent
- Does religion restrict human autonomy and women's equality?
- The fall can be explained without divine punishment
- Divine simplicity conflicts with a contingent intention to create
- The hybrid timeless-and-temporal God model cannot account for time
- A first cause does not establish God
- Intellect without thought is incoherent
- Natural evil is not explained by free will
- A timeless God cannot act at a particular moment
- Dreams do not establish a metaphysical realm
- Logic and order need not depend on God
- Belief is not directly voluntary
- An omniscient God faces a self-referential contradiction
- Physical explanations may be sufficient
- A composed deity cannot be the ultimate efficient cause
- The cross is unnecessary if God freely chose the penalty
- The RNA World: What It Explains and What It Leaves Open
- How Little Does a Living Cell Need? The Minimal Genome Experiments
- Irreducible Complexity and the Bacterial Flagellum
- Is DNA a Code, and What Would Follow If It Is?
- Mechanisms Beyond Natural Selection: The Extended Evolutionary Synthesis
- Epigenetics: What Is Actually Inherited?
- What Makes Human Genomes Distinctive
- Probability Arguments About the Origin of Life
- Evolution explains cooperation without God
- Is Intelligent Design a Scientific Theory?
- The Anthropic Principle: Explanation or Observation Selection?
- Does a Universe With a Beginning Require a Cause?
- Does Randomness Produce Design?
- Randomness Cannot Design
- A flawed mind challenges divine judgment
- A designer may be more complex than the universe explained