Pre-Islamic Arabs did use the name "Allah" for a supreme deity, and Islam retained the name of the Kaaba and some pilgrimage rites. But this does not show that Islam absorbed Allah's pagan cult; it shows that the Quran confronted a corrupted form of belief in the God associated with Abraham.

What the objection gets right

The strongest version of the objection is not that the Arabs had never heard of Allah. They had. The Quran itself says that, if asked who created the heavens and the earth, many Meccans would answer, "Allah" (see Quran 29:61; 31:25). They also associated al-Lat, al-Uzza, and Manat with Him, describing them as "daughters" of Allah. Some pilgrimage customs, including circumambulation and sacrifice, existed before Islam. Later Muslim reports also mention an idol called Hubal in or near the Kaaba.

So there was real continuity in vocabulary, place, and certain rituals. Islam did not appear in a cultural vacuum. A critic may reasonably ask why a wholly new revelation would preserve these features.

What the Quran says about this belief

The Quran does not conceal the Meccans' belief in a high god. It presents it as an inconsistent and idolatrous compromise, not as sound monotheism:

"Have you considered al-Lat and al-Uzza, and Manat, the third one, another goddess? Is the male for you and for Him the female? That, then, is an unfair division. They are only names you have named - you and your fathers - for which Allah has sent down no authority."

Quran 53:19-23

This is a direct rejection of the claim that these goddesses were Allah's daughters. It does not accept their theology and merely remove three names. It denies that they are divine at all, and it rejects the assumption that inherited religious labels prove truth.

The Quran's argument is also theological: a creator who is unique, independent, and unlike creation cannot have divine offspring. "Allah" is the Arabic name for the one God, used by Arabic-speaking Christians and Jews as well. Sharing a name does not mean sharing the same worship, doctrine, or historical cult.

Continuity is not the same as absorption

Islam teaches that the Kaaba was established for the worship of the one God by Abraham and Ishmael, then later filled with idols. Thus the building and some rites could be restored rather than invented. The same principle applies to circumcision, pilgrimage, sacrifice, and other practices connected with earlier prophets: a later revelation may preserve what is sound and remove what is corrupt.

Hubal does not overturn this distinction. His identification, location, and relation to other Meccan deities come mainly through later historical reports, not through an inscription proving that Hubal was simply another name for Allah. Even if an idol stood at the Kaaba, that would establish pagan occupation of a sacred site, not that Allah was originally an idol.

The evidence therefore establishes cultural and ritual continuity, and it shows that Meccans used the name Allah while committing shirk. It does not establish that Islam evolved from a cult of Allah. The Islamic claim is precisely that a genuine monotheistic sanctuary and message were later corrupted, then restored by revelation.