The psychological explanation may account for some apparent "answers" to prayer, but it does not account for prayer itself or prove that God is absent. It confuses a possible human mechanism involved in some outcomes with the full Islamic claim about a living, knowing, and responsive Lord.

Why the objection sounds plausible

The strongest version of the argument is not that every prayer is obviously false. It is that the setting of tahajjud naturally produces effects that self-help psychology also describes: quiet attention, emotional intensity, repeated mental focus, clearer goals, better self-control, and greater readiness to notice or pursue opportunities. A person who prays with confidence may work differently the next day, persist longer, and interpret events through the hope that was formed at night.

Some "answered prayers" may indeed be explained partly in this way. Islam does not require us to deny ordinary psychological causes. A person's changed attitude, disciplined action, and improved judgment can be among the means through which an outcome occurs.

What the Islamic claim actually says

Islam does not teach that every strongly desired request must appear in the exact form imagined by the worshipper. The Quran says:

"Call upon Me; I will respond to you."

Quran 40:60

That promise is a promise of response, not a vending-machine guarantee. The response may be the requested thing, the removal of a harm, a delayed gift, or reward and forgiveness in the Hereafter. The Quran also reminds us that a person may love something that is bad for him and dislike something that is good for him (Quran 2:216).

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) specifically described the special virtue of the last part of the night:

"Our Lord, the Blessed and Exalted, descends every night to the lowest heaven when the last third of the night remains and says: Who is calling upon Me so that I may answer him? Who is asking Me so that I may give him? Who is asking My forgiveness so that I may forgive him?"

Sahih al-Bukhari

Mainstream scholars affirmed this report as it came, without comparing God's descent to the movement or limitations of created beings, and without asking how. It is a revealed claim about God's action, not a psychological technique.

What the evidence does and does not establish

If a person obtains an outcome after tahajjud, that single event usually cannot prove which secondary means were involved. Perhaps the prayer changed his choices; perhaps circumstances independently aligned; perhaps God granted the request through those very means. Human observation alone may not separate these possibilities.

But the existence of a psychological pathway does not disprove divine agency. In Islamic belief, God ordinarily brings things about through causes: medicine may heal, effort may produce success, and prayer may reshape a person's heart and conduct. The relevant question is not whether psychology is involved, but whether psychology exhausts the explanation. It does not establish that consciousness is merely "reprogrammed," nor that the addressed God is imaginary.

Thus, tahajjud is neither a guaranteed manifestation formula nor reducible to self-help. It is worship: asking God, trusting His wisdom, and accepting that His answer may differ from the request while never being meaningless.