The claim is not baseless, but Deuteronomy 33:2 by itself does not plainly identify Muhammad (PBUH), Mecca, or the conquest of Mecca. It is best presented as a cumulative Muslim interpretation, not as an explicit prediction that settles the matter on its own.
What the objection gets right
Deuteronomy 33 is a poetic blessing attributed to Moses. It says that God came from Sinai, dawned from Seir, and shone from Mount Paran, accompanied by holy ones. The surrounding context speaks of God's manifestation to Israel and his giving of the law. The Hebrew verbs are commonly read as describing a past theophany, not a sequence of future prophets.
Nor does the passage say, "A prophet will arise in Paran," or mention Mecca, Arabia, or a military conquest. The "ten thousands" are naturally understood by many Jewish and Christian interpreters as a heavenly assembly or divine entourage, not Muhammad's army. And the Torah's geography does not unambiguously place Paran at Mecca. These points make the critic's case serious.
Why "no textual support" is too strong
There is still a real basis for the Muslim reading. The verse deliberately links several locations with successive manifestations of divine guidance: Sinai, Seir, and Paran. Paran is associated in Genesis with the descendants of Ishmael, although its precise geographical extent remains debated. Muslim interpreters therefore understood the final place as pointing toward the Ishmaelite homeland and a later messenger.
The phrase about "ten thousands" also has an interesting correspondence with the well-known Muslim account of the Prophet's peaceful conquest of Mecca with ten thousand companions. That correspondence does not prove that the verse means this event, but it explains why the passage became significant in Muslim argument. A later event can illuminate an earlier prophecy; that is not automatically dishonest back-projection. The question is whether the text permits the connection.
"Those who follow the Messenger, the unlettered Prophet, whom they find written in what they have of the Torah and the Gospel..."
Quran 7:157
This Quranic statement gives Muslims a reason to expect biblical indications of Muhammad (PBUH), but it does not itself identify Deuteronomy 33:2 as the passage in question. Nor does the absence of a pre-Islamic Jewish or Christian interpretation connecting Paran with Muhammad count as positive evidence against Islam. It does, however, weaken the claim that this was the obvious original meaning.
What the passage establishes
Deuteronomy 33:2 is compatible with a Muslim typological or cumulative reading, especially when Paran's Ishmaelite associations and the ten-thousand correspondence are considered. It is not a standalone, unambiguous prediction of Muhammad (PBUH). The fairest conclusion is that calling the interpretation "textually unsupported" goes too far, while presenting it as a decisive proof ignores the verse's immediate context and the genuine geographical and linguistic uncertainties.