Genesis 49:10 is a serious text for Christian interpretation, but it does not say that every future prophet or bearer of divine guidance must descend from Judah. It concerns Judah's royal authority and the coming ruler associated with it; Muhammad (PBUH) did not claim to be a Davidic king or the Jewish Messiah.
Why the Christian argument has force
Jacob's blessing places Judah in a position of rule among the tribes of Israel. The later biblical story develops that theme through David and his royal house, and Christian readers understand the verse as pointing ultimately to Christ. On that reading, the covenant promise is not an open invitation to a prophet from any lineage. It is tied to Israel, Judah, David, and the expected Messiah.
"The sceptre shall not depart from Judah, nor a lawgiver from between his feet, until Shiloh come; and unto him shall the gathering of the people be."
Genesis 49:10, KJV
That is the strongest form of the objection: if this passage defines the line through which God's decisive saving promise must come, then an Arab prophet claiming descent from Ishmael appears to stand outside it.
What the verse actually establishes
The first difficulty is linguistic. The Hebrew term commonly rendered "Shiloh" is disputed. Translations and commentators have understood it in different ways, including "the one to whom it belongs" or a phrase referring to the arrival of a ruler. So the verse cannot bear more precision than its wording allows.
More importantly, the immediate subject is Judah's scepter - royal authority within Israel. Even if the verse is read messianically, it identifies the Messiah's Israelite and Davidic setting. It does not state that no prophet can ever arise outside Judah, that Ishmael has no place in God's purposes, or that revelation must end with the Davidic line.
Islam does not claim that Muhammad (PBUH) inherited Judah's throne, fulfilled the Davidic monarchy, or was the Messiah promised to Israel. It claims that he was the final prophet sent with a universal message, while Jesus remains the Messiah and a prophet to Israel. Those are distinct claims. A text about the royal Messiah cannot, by itself, disprove a separate claim about a later prophet whose mission is not presented as the continuation of Judah's kingship.
Genealogy is not the whole covenant question
The Bible itself distinguishes between different divine promises. God promised Abraham that Ishmael would be blessed and become a great nation, while the particular covenant associated with Isaac was also affirmed. Thus, even within Genesis, blessing, nationhood, covenantal succession, kingship, and prophethood are not simply identical categories.
The Quran likewise presents revelation as returning to the religion of Abraham, not as Muhammad (PBUH) becoming a Judahite. Whether one accepts that claim depends on the wider evidence for his prophethood: his message, character, revelation, and continuity with the worship of the one God.
Therefore, Genesis 49:10 can support a Christian argument about the identity of the Messiah and the Davidic royal line. It does not establish that Muhammad (PBUH) is impossible as a later prophet, nor does it show that Islam's claim fails merely because his lineage is not Judahite.