Islam does not define a Muslim as someone who submits to whatever they happen to call God. It means submitting to Allah - the one true God - as He has made Himself known through revelation, and worshipping Him alone.

Why the objection has force

The objection correctly exposes a weakness in a purely dictionary-level definition. If "Islam" simply meant surrendering to any being a person regards as divine, then a person could submit to a statue, a mythical deity, or even treat a human being as God and still claim to be Muslim. That would make the word almost empty.

Islamic teaching does not accept that loose definition. "Submission" describes the posture of the believer, but the object of submission is not left undefined. The Quran repeatedly joins submission with exclusive worship of Allah and obedience to His messengers.

What Islam actually requires

Indeed, the religion in the sight of Allah is Islam.

Quran 3:19

This does not mean that every form of religious sincerity is Islam. The same Quran explains what Islam involves:

Say, "He is Allah, [who is] One. Allah, the Eternal Refuge. He neither begets nor is born, nor is there to Him any equivalent."

Quran 112:1-4

Thus, a statue, a created person, or an imagined deity cannot be the God whom Islam commands people to worship. Allah is the uncreated Creator, unique, independent, and without equal. He is also known through His names, attributes, commands, and acts described in the Quran and authentic Sunnah.

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) gave the practical definition plainly:

Islam is to testify that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, to establish prayer, give zakah, fast Ramadan, and perform pilgrimage to the House if you are able to do so.

Sahih Muslim, hadith of Jibril

So the claim that Islam requires a specifically revealed God is correct, with one refinement: Allah is not made divine merely by the Muslim label. He is the God of Abraham and all the prophets, and revelation identifies Him and distinguishes Him from false gods. The Quran says that the prophets called people to worship one God and reject all rivals.

What this argument establishes

The argument successfully refutes the idea that Islam is submission to an undefined "higher power." It also shows why tawhid - worshipping Allah alone - is not an optional detail but the foundation of Islam. A person who worships a statue or a human being has not submitted to Allah, whatever language they use.

By itself, however, this argument does not prove that the Quran is divine or that Muhammad (PBUH) is a prophet. Those are further questions, answered through the Quran's message, its evidence, and the Prophet's life. What this point establishes is the correct target of submission: not any supposed god, but Allah as revealed in Islam.