The objection identifies a real feature of classical Islamic law: qisas is normally a right of the victim's heirs, and the majority of classical jurists assigned a woman's diyya as half a man's. But these rules do not mean that a woman's life is spiritually worth half as much, nor do they make murder a simple purchase available to the rich.
What the objection gets right
Under classical qisas law, the heirs of the murdered person have a recognized claim. They may demand qisas, accept diyya, or pardon without payment. This differs from a purely state-controlled model of criminal justice. A critic can therefore fairly ask why a wealthy killer should be able to escape execution by offering compensation.
The gender distinction is also real in the dominant classical position: the diyya for a free Muslim woman was generally assessed at half the diyya for a free Muslim man. Likewise, qisas requires demanding standards of proof. A wife might be a witness, but her testimony would not necessarily establish a capital offense by itself under the rules of many classical schools. These are serious legal asymmetries, not inventions of modern critics.
What Quran 2:178 actually establishes
O believers, prescribed for you is legal retribution (qisas) in cases of murder: the free for the free, the slave for the slave, and the female for the female. But whoever is pardoned by the victim's guardian, then the bloodwit should be decided fairly, and payment should be made courteously.
Quran 2:178
The verse presents qisas as one option, but also makes pardon and compensation lawful. Its language is not a price list for human worth. Diyya serves as financial redress for the victim's dependents and as a means of preventing continuing cycles of vengeance. The heirs' authority is also constrained by law: they cannot impose arbitrary punishment, and accepting diyya does not turn murder into a business transaction in which anyone may simply pay a posted fee.
Moreover, qisas does not exhaust the ruler's responsibility. Classical jurists allowed discretionary punishment (ta'zir) where public harm, corruption, coercion, or aggravating circumstances required it. A killer cannot claim immunity from every punishment merely because the heirs pardon him. Nor may the state permit bribery or pressure to manufacture a pardon.
Does the gender rule declare unequal human value?
The classical rule does create unequal financial liability. That should be stated plainly rather than concealed. Classical jurists connected diyya to financial obligations and economic loss, not to a theological ranking of souls. The Quran repeatedly grounds moral accountability in faith and conduct, not sex. It also condemns oppression and corruption:
Would you then, if given authority, spread corruption throughout the land and sever your ties of kinship?
Quran 47:22
The strongest criticism, then, is that these rules may appear unjust when judged by a modern principle that identical lives must receive identical compensation and that all homicide must be prosecuted solely as a public crime. That criticism raises a genuine jurisprudential and ethical debate. It does not, however, prove that Islam permits the rich to buy murder, or that the Quran teaches women are worth fifty percent of men. It shows that the classical legal framework distinguishes moral worth, criminal procedure, and financial remedy - distinctions one may debate, but should not collapse into a literal price tag on a human life.