Quran 43:81 does not concede that a divine son would be worthy of worship. It uses a conditional, rhetorical statement to expose the absurdity of attributing a son to God, while affirming that the premise itself is false.
Why the objection sounds plausible
The argument is not foolish. The verse says that if the Most Merciful had a son, Muhammad (PBUH) would be the first of those who worship him. A reader might therefore reason: if the Son existed, worshipping him would be proper; so the disagreement between Islam and Christianity would concern only whether the Son exists.
That is the strongest form of the objection. But it still treats a rhetorical conditional as though it were a theological endorsement.
What the verse actually says
Say, "If the Most Merciful had a son, then I would be the first of the worshippers."
Quran 43:81
The verse does not say, "The son of God would be worthy of worship," nor does it say, "If God has a son, worship him." It presents a hypothetical premise and describes what would follow if that premise were true. A conditional statement does not establish that its condition is possible or real. For example, "If the sun rose in the west, I would be astonished" does not affirm that the sun can or will rise in the west.
The immediate context makes the intent even clearer:
Glory be to the Lord of the heavens and the earth, Lord of the Throne, above what they describe.
Quran 43:82
The surrounding passage is rejecting the claim, not granting it. Classical commentators therefore understood the verse as a rhetorical challenge and a declaration of complete submission to the truth. Some also discussed whether "the first of the worshippers" carries the sense of being first to worship if the premise were true, or first to reject and disassociate from such a claim. Those differences concern the nuance of the expression, not the Quran's central teaching: God has no son.
Why the premise conflicts with Islamic theology
In Islam, worship belongs to God because He alone is the Creator, Lord, and absolutely independent being. A created son could never share in that right. And if "Son" means, as in Christian theology, an eternal divine person rather than a created child, then the claim is not a minor exception to monotheism. It is precisely the claim the Quran denies: that God has partners or persons sharing His divinity.
Thus the verse neither vindicates Christian worship nor concedes its principle. It says, in effect: if this impossible attribution were true, the Prophet would not oppose the truth; but God is exalted above having a son. The verse is a conditional rejection, not permission to worship anyone besides God.