Yes, harsh and careless takfir can push sincere people away, and those who use it bear real responsibility before Allah. But this condemns a serious misuse of Islam, not Islam itself; the Quran and Sunnah place strict limits on declaring a Muslim outside the faith.
Why the objection has force
The objection should not be dismissed as mere hostility. A person who asks whether a hadith is authentic, struggles with a difficult ruling, or fails in religious practice may be seeking understanding rather than rejecting Islam. If the first response is insult, suspicion, or takfir, the community has failed both morally and intellectually. Someone may reasonably ask: if this religion produces constant condemnation, does that not count against its divine origin?
That concern is especially serious for women who do not wear hijab, or for people who are uncertain about particular hadith. A sinful act, confusion, or an unanswered question is not automatically apostasy. Treating every weakness as disbelief creates fear and hypocrisy rather than faith.
What the Quran and Sunnah actually require
The Quran itself rebukes religious mockery and warns that some people who thought they were only joking had crossed a grave line:
"Make no excuse; you have disbelieved after your belief."
Quran 9:65-66
This does not give ordinary people permission to pronounce takfir whenever they are offended. It shows that disbelief is a serious judgment, not a casual insult. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) also warned:
"If a man says to his brother, 'O kafir,' then surely one of them is such."
Sahih al-Bukhari 6103
Mainstream scholars therefore distinguish between saying that a belief or statement is disbelief in principle, and declaring a particular person a disbeliever. The latter requires knowledge, clarity, consideration of ignorance, misunderstanding, coercion, and other barriers. It is not the task of untrained individuals to make such judgments.
Likewise, not wearing hijab is a serious sin according to the established law, but a Muslim woman is not thereby automatically outside Islam. Denying a known obligation is a different matter from failing to practise it, and even then individual judgments require proper scholarship and due process. Asking whether a hadith is authentic is not the same as rejecting revelation; hadith criticism is itself a recognized Islamic discipline.
What this does and does not establish
The conduct of Muslim communities is evidence about those communities, not a reliable test of the Quran's truth. Christians, Jews, atheists, and Muslims can all represent their beliefs badly; bad representatives do not logically disprove the belief they claim. Yet this answer must not become an excuse. When Muslims drive sincere questioners away through arrogance or reckless takfir, they have acted against the religion they claim to defend.
The right response is firm teaching joined to patience, evidence, and mercy. Islam does not require pretending that every doubt is correct, but it does require answering the doubter justly and never confusing sin, ignorance, and honest inquiry with apostasy.