The Sinai argument identifies a real difference: Israel's founding tradition presents revelation as a public event, while the first revelation to Muhammad (PBUH) came privately in the cave of Hira. But that difference does not by itself prove that the Torah's present form is true in every detail, or that Islam rests on one man's unsupported testimony.

Why the argument is serious

The strongest version of the argument is this: Moses' revelation was not allegedly seen by Moses alone. Exodus describes the Israelites gathered at Sinai, hearing divine speech amid thunder, fire, and the voice of the trumpet. Exodus 12:37 speaks of about six hundred thousand men on foot, besides women and children. The claim, then, is national: an entire people supposedly witnessed its founding revelation and transmitted it together. It would be difficult for a later leader to invent such an event and persuade the whole nation that they had seen it.

That is stronger than saying, "One person had a private experience, so believe him." It also explains why Jewish tradition regards the Sinai event as a public historical foundation rather than merely a prophet's personal report.

What this argument actually establishes

It gives a serious reason to investigate the Sinai tradition. It does not automatically establish that the event occurred exactly as later texts describe, nor that the entire Torah in its present textual form was publicly dictated there. The argument depends on the reliability of the text's account, the continuity of the people who transmitted it, and the connection between that later community and the original witnesses.

Large communities can preserve genuine memories, but collective transmission is not infallible. A people may preserve a real event while later disputes arise over its wording, interpretation, chronology, or the extent of what was actually witnessed. Even if Sinai is accepted, it would still be necessary to determine what Moses taught and whether later textual history preserved it without alteration.

Islam's evidence is not merely a private cave

Islam does not ask people to accept Muhammad's (PBUH) first experience simply because he reported it. His claim was tested publicly over approximately twenty-three years. His followers memorized and wrote the Quran, recited it in worship, challenged one another with it, and transmitted it as a community. His character, message, prophecies, moral teaching, and the Quran itself were open to scrutiny by friends and enemies alike.

The Quran's origin is therefore private at the moment of first reception, but public in proclamation, preservation, and examination. A revelation must first be received by a messenger; otherwise there is no revelation at all. The relevant question is whether that messenger is trustworthy and whether the message bears signs of divine origin.

What Quran 10:94 means

So, if you are in doubt about what We have revealed to you, then ask those who have been reading the Scripture before you. The truth has certainly come to you from your Lord, so do not be one of those who doubt.

Quran 10:94

This verse acknowledges that earlier scripture contained genuine revelation and points to knowledgeable scriptural communities as witnesses to truths confirmed by the Quran. It does not say that every later textual form of the Torah is automatically decisive, or that Islam surrenders its evidence to another tradition. Thus, Sinai may be evidence for revelation, but it is not a proof that overrides the Quran without further argument.