This argument rightly highlights that the Quran regards the Torah as a real revelation containing guidance, and that Israelite prophets judged by God's revealed law. But it does not establish that every later copy of the Torah remained perfectly preserved, nor that prophets were appointed as permanent guardians of every written manuscript.
Why the argument is serious
The objection has a genuine Quranic basis. Moses was given the Book, and messengers came after him. The Torah is described as containing guidance and light, while prophets, rabbis, and scholars judged by it. The Quran also says that the People of the Book recognized the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) from what they had, and an authentic hadith describes the prophets of Israel as succeeding one another in governing their people.
"Indeed, We sent down the Torah, in which was guidance and light. The prophets who submitted judged by it for the Jews, as did the rabbis and scholars, by that with which they were entrusted of the Scripture of Allah."
Quran 5:44
So the strongest form of the case is this: if prophets are protected from deliberately teaching falsehood in religion, and if one prophet continually succeeds another, why would corruption ever enter the Torah?
What these verses actually guarantee
The answer is that prophetic protection concerns faithfully conveying God's revelation; it does not mean that every community, scribe, copy, or later interpreter is protected from error. The hadith says that prophets governed Israel, not that each prophet personally inspected and secured every written copy until the next prophet arrived.
"They distort words from their proper places and have forgotten a portion of what they were reminded of."
Quran 5:13
This describes both distortion and loss within the religious community. It does not require the implausible idea that a prophet himself deliberately falsified revelation. A text may be altered, selectively transmitted, misread, or partly concealed by people who are not prophets. A later prophet may restore the truth without having preserved every intervening manuscript.
Nor does "the Torah" in Quran 5:44 have to mean that every line found in every later textual form is untouched. It can refer to the divine revelation and to the scriptural corpus that still contained genuine guidance. The Quran often speaks this way: it acknowledges truth remaining with earlier communities while also censuring concealment and distortion.
What "written with them" establishes
Quran 7:157 supports the presence of authentic information about Muhammad (PBUH) in the earlier scriptures available to some of their people. Quran 2:146 similarly says that some recognized him as they recognize their own sons. These verses establish surviving testimony, not the perfect preservation of the entire Torah or Gospel.
"Those to whom We gave the Scripture recognize him as they recognize their own sons, but indeed a group of them knowingly conceal the truth."
Quran 2:146
Thus, the argument proves that the original Torah was divine, that substantial truth remained among its custodians, and that prophets continued to judge by God's revelation. It does not prove an unbroken, word-for-word textual transmission. The Quran's position is more precise: revelation is from God, genuine remnants can remain, and human communities can distort, lose, or conceal parts of what they received.