The argument is decisive only against a deity whose visibility means bodily presence, spatial limitation, and dependence. Islam does not teach that Allah is a body located in the universe; it teaches that He is unseen in this life, while the believers will see Him in the Hereafter in a manner that does not make Him comparable to created things.
Why the objection is philosophically serious
The strongest form of the objection runs as follows: ordinary sight is directed toward something within a relation of distance and position. If a deity is visible to physical eyes, then He seems to occupy a place, have boundaries, and be composed of parts or dimensions. Whatever is spatially located and composed depends on conditions outside itself. It would therefore be a created object, not the necessary and transcendent Creator.
This is not a foolish objection. If someone claimed that God is literally a large body inside the cosmos, with measurable size and a physical location, the objection would succeed. Such a being would not be Allah.
What the Quran actually teaches
The Quran denies that Allah resembles created things and denies that worldly vision can encompass Him:
There is nothing like Him, and He is the All-Hearing, the All-Seeing.
Quran 42:11
Vision cannot encompass Him, but He encompasses all vision.
Quran 6:103
At the same time, it describes the believers in the Hereafter as looking toward their Lord:
On that Day faces will be radiant, looking at their Lord.
Quran 75:22-23
These verses are not contradictory. "Vision cannot encompass Him" means that created sight cannot contain, measure, or fully grasp Allah. It does not necessarily mean that seeing Him is impossible in every mode of existence. The Quran itself affirms the vision of Allah in the Hereafter, while denying that He can be comprehended or compared with creation.
Seeing does not turn the Creator into a creature
The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said that the believers will see their Lord as clearly as they see the full moon, while emphasizing that this comparison concerns the clarity of seeing, not resemblance between Allah and the moon. This is recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim.
Mainstream classical scholarship therefore affirmed the vision of Allah in the Hereafter without describing its mechanism or assigning Allah a body, direction, size, or location. The act of seeing is a relation involving the observer; it does not by itself prove that the thing seen is composed, finite, or dependent. Those conclusions follow only if one assumes that divine vision must work exactly like ordinary vision in this world.
What the argument establishes
The argument establishes that a physically located and limited god cannot be the true God. Islam agrees. It does not establish that the promised vision of Allah in the Hereafter entails bodily form, because the Quran explicitly combines that vision with Allah's absolute incomparability.
So the Islamic position is neither that God is an invisible object nor that He is a visible body. Allah is unlike creation, and the manner of seeing Him belongs to the realities of the Hereafter, not to the limitations of present experience.