The objection exposes a real difficulty for a particular Christian reading of Daniel, but it does not disprove Islam. It assumes that Daniel 7 teaches a simple sequence in which Rome must be militarily destroyed by one clearly identifiable successor, whereas the chapter itself does not state that interpretation in those terms.

The argument in its strongest form

On the traditional reading, the four beasts in Daniel 7 represent Babylon, Medo-Persia, Greece, and Rome. The fourth kingdom is portrayed as unusually terrifying, with ten horns and a later "little horn." If the final kingdom is to be brought down decisively, then the Roman Empire should remain the relevant power until that judgment.

This creates a serious historical objection to identifying Islam, or the Ottoman Empire, with Daniel's fulfillment. The Western Roman Empire had already fragmented centuries before the Ottoman conquest. In 1204, Constantinople was captured by Latin Christians, and in 1453 it fell to the Ottomans. Yet the Ottoman rulers presented themselves as successors to Roman imperial authority. They did not simply destroy an intact Roman kingdom; they inherited and continued much of its political world. On this reading, neither event plainly matches Daniel's pattern.

What Daniel actually requires

The difficulty is that several steps in this argument are interpretations rather than explicit statements in the text. Daniel does not name Rome, the Ottomans, Constantinople, or a rule that the fourth kingdom must remain politically unified until its final overthrow. The identification of the fourth beast with Rome is a traditional interpretation, but it is not a quotation from Daniel itself.

Nor does Daniel describe the final judgment as merely one empire defeating another in an ordinary succession. The decisive act is God's judgment:

"The beast was slain, and its body destroyed and given to the burning flame. As for the rest of the beasts, their dominion was taken away."

Daniel 7:11-12

The chapter then speaks of the Son of Man receiving an everlasting kingdom. That language points beyond a normal imperial transfer. The earlier kingdoms may be represented through historical empires, while their ultimate removal awaits divine judgment. Consequently, the fragmentation of Rome does not by itself refute every reading of the prophecy, and Ottoman rule could be viewed as one stage in the long political aftermath of Rome rather than a clean replacement.

What this establishes - and what it does not

The objection does establish that a confident claim such as "Daniel clearly predicts the Ottoman conquest of Rome in 1453" is historically and textually weak. The facts do not fit neatly, and the Ottoman claim to Roman succession makes the proposed fulfillment ambiguous. Christians themselves have therefore offered different readings: some see the fourth kingdom as Rome and its successor states, while others expect a future final empire.

But this does not establish that Islam is false. Islam does not depend on Daniel 7 as its sole proof, nor does the Quran present a detailed identification of Daniel's beasts. At most, the argument shows that one proposed prophetic correlation is debatable. It neither disproves the truth of Islam nor proves it. A fair conclusion is modest: Daniel 7 cannot serve as a straightforward, decisive argument that Islam must fulfill a Roman-kingdom timeline, but neither can the Ottoman-Roman history be used as a decisive refutation of Islam.