The existence of different madhhabs does not mean Islam has several competing revelations. It means fallible jurists used different methods to understand the Quran and Sunnah, and a sahih hadith is not always a complete legal argument by itself.

Why the objection sounds serious

The objection is not simply that scholars made minor mistakes. It points to real differences: al-Shafi'i's ruling concerning passage in front of a person praying, Abu Hanifa's position on congregational prayer for rain and on a fetus found in a slaughtered animal, and Malik's allowance of singling out Friday for fasting. In each case, critics argue, an explicit report seems to settle the matter. If the hadith is authentic, why follow an imam whose ruling appears to oppose it?

This is a fair question, especially when "authentic hadith" is treated as if it automatically means "unambiguous legal ruling." But the four imams did not regard themselves as alternatives to the Prophet (PBUH). They were attempting to determine what the total evidence required.

What a sahih hadith does and does not establish

A hadith may have an authentic chain while its legal meaning remains subject to discussion. A jurist must ask whether it is general or specific, absolute or qualified, later or earlier, and how it fits with other reports and the established practice of the Companions. He must also determine whether a report actually addresses the precise case under discussion.

"When a judge exercises judgment and is correct, he will have two rewards; and when he exercises judgment and is mistaken, he will have one reward."

Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim

For example, the narrations about a sutra in Sahih Muslim establish an important rule concerning the space in front of the worshipper. The juristic disagreement concerns the extent of that space and the precise legal status of passing through it, not a rejection of the Prophet's practice. Similarly, the hadith, "The slaughter of the fetus is covered by the slaughter of its mother" (Jami at-Tirmidhi 1476), was interpreted by jurists alongside other evidence concerning whether the fetus is born alive and how it is to be treated.

How the particular examples are understood

The Hanafi position on the rain prayer reflects their assessment of the reports and the inherited practice, not a claim that the Prophet (PBUH) never prayed for rain. They regarded supplication and other forms of seeking rain as firmly established, while disputing whether a regularly prescribed congregational prayer had been established with sufficient legal force.

As for fasting Friday alone, the hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari (1985) clearly discourages singling Friday out. Malik's position reflects a different evaluation of whether this is a strict prohibition or a prohibition connected to treating Friday as a special festival of fasting. The disagreement is over legal interpretation, not over whether the hadith exists.

What this proves about taqlid

It proves that madhhab rulings are not infallible revelation. A qualified scholar may prefer another view when the evidence warrants it, and the imams themselves did not demand blind loyalty. It does not prove that ordinary Muslims should personally overrule centuries of legal expertise whenever they find a translation of one hadith online.

For a non-specialist, taqlid means relying on qualified scholarship, as the Quran instructs: "Ask the people of knowledge if you do not know" (Quran 16:43). It is not believing an imam outranks the Prophet (PBUH). The madhhabs preserve disciplined ways of following the divine sources, while their disagreements show the limits of human interpretation, not a contradiction in revelation.