The objection identifies a real danger: if the only reason for accepting the Quran's standards is that the Quran states them, the argument would be circular. But Muslims are not required to argue that way. The Quran's claims can be treated as proposed tests, then examined through evidence that does not presuppose its divine origin.
Why the objection is serious
The argument can be stated strongly. The Quran says that its message contains no contradiction and challenges doubters to produce a surah like it. A believer then points to the absence of contradiction and the failure of the challenge as proof that the Quran is divine. But a book cannot simply write its own examination rules and declare itself the winner. A person making that argument would be reasoning from "the Quran says it is miraculous" to "therefore it is miraculous."
That criticism is fair if this is the whole argument. Nor can a non-Muslim be expected to accept the Quran's authority before the question of its authority has been established.
What the verses actually invite
Do they not reflect deeply on the Quran? Had it been from anyone other than Allah, they would have found in it many inconsistencies.
Quran 4:82
If you are in doubt about what We have sent down to Our servant, then produce a surah like it and call your witnesses other than Allah, if you are truthful.
Quran 2:23
These are not merely arbitrary rules, like a contestant inventing a private scoring system. They point to publicly examinable features: whether a long, delivered message has serious internal conflict, and whether its language, structure, force, and mode of expression can be matched within the relevant genre and circumstances. The Quran is asserting that these features are evidence of its source, not proving the claim simply by repeating it.
There is also a difference between a text proposing a test and a reader accepting the result. One may investigate the Quran's historical transmission, its language and literary form, its treatment of theology and law, the circumstances of its revelation, and the character and circumstances of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). The Quran's challenge can then function as one part of a cumulative case, rather than as a premise secretly assumed at the start.
What this establishes - and what it does not
The challenge is not a mathematical proof that compels every reader. Judgments about literary uniqueness require Arabic competence, comparison, and careful standards; claims about contradiction also require sound interpretation rather than isolated quotations. Classical Muslim scholars therefore discussed language, context, abrogation, general and specific wording, and apparent tensions before declaring a contradiction.
So the objection successfully exposes a weak, circular presentation of the argument. It does not show that the Quran's criteria are illegitimate, or that they cannot be independently investigated. The reasonable Muslim claim is cumulative: the Quran invites scrutiny, its proposed signs withstand serious examination, and those signs are joined by historical and theological evidence. That is an argument for its divine origin, not a conclusion smuggled in as a premise.