Love of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is indispensable to faith and can open the heart to knowledge of Allah. But love by itself, understood as an inner feeling without obedience, worship, and purification, is not sufficient to guarantee tajalli or spiritual knowledge.
The strongest form of the argument
The argument has a serious point. The Prophet (PBUH) is the finest guide to Allah, and love for him is not merely emotional attachment. Through him we received the Quran, the Sunnah, and the model of ihsan. If the gifts of the saints are understood as blessings Allah grants through the Prophetic guidance, then one may ask why a particular mystical formula, such as Sirul Asrar or a prescribed wird, should be needed. Perhaps sincere mahabbah itself brings the servant to divine unveiling, while insisting on a special practice risks making a human method seem necessary where Allah has not made it necessary.
That is a fair argument against treating any later wird as an unavoidable condition of salvation or nearness to Allah. No specific mystical book or formula can be made obligatory without proof from revelation.
What love of the Prophet actually requires
The Quran connects love for Allah with following the Prophet (PBUH), not with a feeling detached from practice:
Say: If you love Allah, then follow me; Allah will love you and forgive you your sins. And Allah is Forgiving, Merciful.
Quran 3:31
Thus, genuine love includes belief, prayer, repentance, lawful conduct, remembrance, and submission to the Prophetic Sunnah. The Prophet (PBUH) said:
None of you truly believes until I am more beloved to him than his father, his child, and all people.
Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim
This establishes the greatness of Prophetic love, but the same religion also commands worship of Allah, obedience to His revelation, and purification of the soul. Love is the root; it is not a replacement for the tree's branches and fruit.
Tajalli, spiritual knowledge, and prescribed wirds
Tajalli is a term used by spiritual authors for a manifestation of divine illumination in the heart. It is not a guarantee that follows mechanically from a particular emotion or formula. Allah gives understanding and nearness as He wills, while the servant takes the prescribed means. The hadith of ihsan describes the highest spiritual excellence as worshipping Allah with the awareness that He sees you, and striving for certainty in His presence. It does not make a later wird a universal requirement.
A wird may be beneficial when its words and manner are sound, and when it helps a person persevere in Quran, salat, dhikr, and repentance. But it cannot replace these duties, nor may claims of unveiling override the Quran and authentic Sunnah. Karamat are gifts from Allah; they are not independent effects of the Prophet's miracles, and possessing them is not proof of superior rank.
Therefore, Prophetic love can be a profound means to tajalli and knowledge of Allah, but the argument does not establish that love alone is sufficient, nor that every seeker needs Sirul Asrar. It establishes the centrality of love; revelation determines how that love becomes a lived path.