The Prophet's illiteracy is not, by itself, a mathematical proof that the Quran is divine. Its force is cumulative: a man who neither read nor wrote produced a scripture that confirmed, corrected, and challenged earlier religious claims while presenting itself as revelation.

Why the objection has real force

The critic's argument is not foolish. Muhammad (PBUH) could have heard biblical stories through conversation, travel, or the oral culture of Arabia. Being unable to read does not make someone unintelligent, nor does it prevent access to information. His followers also could not independently compare every claim with manuscripts. On this view, the argument from illiteracy risks becoming circular: we believe the Quran is revelation because the Prophet said so, and believe his claim because he could not have read the Bible.

That would indeed be weak reasoning if illiteracy were the only evidence. It is not.

What the Quran actually claims

You did not read any scripture before this, nor did you write it with your right hand; otherwise, the falsifiers would have had doubts.

Quran 29:48

The verse does not say that every person must accept the message merely because Muhammad (PBUH) could not read. It identifies the absence of prior literary study as relevant to the origin of the Quran. The question is whether its content and form are reasonably explained by the Prophet's own learning, or whether revelation is the better explanation.

The Quran also describes him as the "unlettered Prophet" and says that his description was found in the Torah and Gospel:

Those who follow the Messenger, the unlettered Prophet, whom they find written in the Torah and the Gospel with them...

Quran 7:157

"Unlettered" is the usual meaning in this context, though the Arabic term can also carry the sense of belonging to a people without a revealed scripture. Either way, the argument is not that he possessed no knowledge. It is that he was not trained through reading earlier scriptures.

Why this is evidence, but not a shortcut

The earliest Muslims did not rely on illiteracy alone. They heard the Quran publicly, memorized it, wrote it down, examined its teachings, and observed the Prophet's character and conduct over years. The Quran invited scrutiny, reflection, and challenge. Its claim to confirm earlier revelation also includes correction: it does not simply repeat whatever biblical material may have circulated in Arabia.

Could Muhammad (PBUH) have learned religious ideas orally? In principle, yes. That possibility must be admitted. But possibility is not the same as a convincing historical explanation for the Quran's sustained discourse, theological framework, literary form, and influence on the man who proclaimed it.

So the plain answer is this: illiteracy does not establish prophethood by itself, and it does not remove the need for evidence. It does, however, make the Quran's origin harder to explain as the product of reading and deliberate borrowing. In the wider case - the message, the Messenger, the Quran, and its transmission - it is a meaningful sign, not blind faith.