The objection is strong against an exaggerated claim: the full traditional biography cannot be proved from documents written during Muhammad's (PBUH) lifetime. But it does not follow that the historical Muhammad, the Quran he proclaimed, or the broad outline of his mission is unverifiable.
What the objection rightly points out
A careful critic grants that an Arab leader named Muhammad existed in the seventh century, but asks for more. Where is a contemporary diary recording his birth in 570, his life in Mecca, each event in the sira, and the Quran's revelation from 610 to 632? The earliest complete biographies available to us were written later and transmitted through authors who selected, arranged, and sometimes evaluated earlier reports. That is a real limitation. Muslim scholarship should not pretend that every popular story has the same historical status.
Nor should the traditional date of birth, or every detail of the sira, be presented as though it rests on a surviving first-person document. Ancient history rarely works that way. We do not possess contemporary biographies of most major figures of late antiquity, yet their existence and major actions can still be established through early texts, material evidence, and converging reports.
What the earliest evidence does establish
The Quran is the earliest and most direct evidence. It presents itself as the recitation of Muhammad's public mission, addresses events and opponents in his setting, and was being memorized, written, and circulated among his followers during his lifetime. Early Quran manuscripts and inscriptions from the first Islamic century fit this picture. The Quran also repeatedly identifies its messenger and the community forming around him:
Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, and those with him are forceful against the disbelievers, merciful among themselves.
Quran 48:29
Early non-Muslim witnesses also refer to an Arab prophet or leader named Muhammad within decades of his death. These notices are brief and sometimes polemical, but they independently confirm the basic setting: an Arabian preacher led a movement that proclaimed one God and spread rapidly under his leadership. Coins, inscriptions, papyri, and the early Islamic administrative record reinforce the existence of this movement and its connection to Muhammad.
How the later reports should be assessed
The later sira is not simply a late invention. It preserves earlier material through named transmitters, parallel accounts, Quranic allusions, early hadith collections, and reports transmitted by different regional authorities. Classical scholars did not treat every report equally: they examined chains, transmitters, wording, contradictions, and whether a report conflicted with stronger evidence. This method does not make every narration certain, but it can establish many events with reasonable historical confidence.
Historical evidence can establish that Muhammad (PBUH) lived, preached the Quran, formed a community, migrated to Medina, and led it until his death. It cannot, by itself, prove revelation as a divine event; that is also a theological judgment based on the Quran's claims and signs. Nor can it guarantee every chronological detail in later popular biographies.
So the fair conclusion is limited but substantial: the absence of a contemporary biography weakens claims of absolute documentary certainty, not the core historical portrait on which Islamic practice rests.