Muslims and Christians do refer, in their historical and intended worship, to the Creator worshipped by Abraham, Moses, and Jesus. But they do not hold the same doctrine about Him, and Islam regards the Christian claims about divine sonship and the Trinity as serious errors about that one Creator.

Why the objection has force

The objection is not merely about different names. Christianity describes God as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, with the Son sharing the divine nature. Islam describes Allah as absolutely one, without offspring, partner, or division, and says that all creation stands before Him as servant. If "God is Father and has a divine Son" and "God is neither father nor son" are taken as essential descriptions, the two concepts appear mutually exclusive. On that basis, a critic may argue that Muslims and Christians are not worshipping the same being at all.

That is a serious philosophical point: contradictory descriptions cannot both be true in the same sense. Islam does not try to solve it by pretending that the doctrines are equivalent. It plainly rejects the Christian doctrine of divine sonship.

What the Quran actually claims

"And do not argue with the People of the Scripture except in a way that is best - except those of them who commit injustice - and say, 'We believe in what was revealed to us and what was revealed to you. Our God and your God is one; and we are Muslims in submission to Him.'"

Quran 29:46

This verse identifies a shared referent: the God who sent revelation to the prophets. It does not say that Muslims and Christians possess equally correct descriptions of Him. A person can refer to someone real while making false claims about that person. Two people may speak about the same historical figure while one attributes to him actions he never performed. Disagreement, even deep disagreement, does not by itself prove that the intended referent is different.

Servanthood and divine sonship

"There is no one in the heavens and earth but that he comes to the Most Merciful as a servant."

Quran 19:93

In the Quran, being a servant is not an insult or a denial of human dignity. It means being a created dependent of God. Jesus himself is honored as Messiah and prophet, but not as God's literal or ontological son. The Quran's rejection of sonship is therefore a rejection of a doctrine about God, not a claim that Christians consciously intended to worship a pagan deity unrelated to the God of Abraham.

At the same time, Islam does not erase the practical difference. Worship directed to Jesus, or belief that God became incarnate, is false and may become shirk. Thus the strongest Islamic judgment is precise: there is a shared claimed Creator and historical referent, but the Christian conception contains grave theological errors. The argument successfully shows that the two religions do not worship God according to the same doctrine; it does not establish that they intend two wholly unrelated gods.