No, becoming Muslim does not require a convert to abandon non-Muslim parents, relatives, or friends. Islam requires faithfulness to God, but it also commands kindness, family duty, and justice toward people who do not fight or persecute Muslims.

Why this objection can seem persuasive

The concern is not invented. The Quran warns believers against taking certain opponents as close allies, and a convert may also meet Muslims who speak as though every non-Muslim relationship is spiritually dangerous. If "loyalty" means sharing or defending false belief, then a Muslim cannot offer that kind of loyalty. But if it means love, good manners, practical help, and maintaining family ties, the Quran makes a clear distinction.

What the Quran actually requires

The strongest example concerns parents. Even when they pressure their child to commit the gravest religious wrong, Islam does not permit cruelty or abandonment:

But if they strive to make you associate with Me that of which you have no knowledge, then do not obey them, but accompany them in this world with kindness, and follow the way of those who turn to Me.

Quran 31:15

The instruction is precise: do not obey them in shirk, but still accompany them with kindness. A convert may refuse religious participation that contradicts Islam while continuing to visit, speak gently, provide reasonable support, and care for elderly or vulnerable parents.

The general rule is also stated plainly:

Allah does not forbid you from being kind and equitable to those who have not fought you because of religion and have not expelled you from your homes. Indeed, Allah loves those who act equitably.

Quran 60:8

The next verse refers to those who fight Muslims because of religion and drive them from their homes. Thus, the prohibited form of alliance concerns hostile persecution, treachery, and support for wrongdoing - not ordinary friendship with a peaceful neighbor, colleague, sibling, or parent.

How the Prophet's example clarifies it

Asma bint Abi Bakr asked the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) about maintaining relations with her non-Muslim mother. He told her to maintain ties with her mother. This report is recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, and it directly addresses the situation of a Muslim whose parent does not share the faith.

Classical scholars therefore distinguished between religious allegiance and natural affection and duty. A Muslim cannot say that another religion is true merely to preserve peace, nor obey a parent in disobedience to God. But Islam does not demand hatred, neglect, or social isolation. It asks the convert to preserve faith without answering family pressure with arrogance or cruelty.

So the objection establishes a real boundary, but not the conclusion often drawn from it. A convert must not compromise worship or support injustice; they should nevertheless keep family ties, show kindness, and remain a source of mercy to their non-Muslim relatives and friends.