The consistency objection is strong against a careless argument, but it does not refute Islam. A disaster cannot by itself prove that Allah has condemned one population for idolatry, nor does a disaster in Mecca or a Muslim country prove that Islam is false.
Why the objection appears to work
The critic is right to press the logic. If a flood in a Hindu area is declared to be Allah destroying idols, then earthquakes in Turkey, floods in Mecca, or disasters affecting Muslims should supposedly be read as Allah condemning Islam. Since calamities strike people of every religion, the original argument looks like selective interpretation: judgment when it supports Islam, but merely a test when it does not.
That criticism succeeds against anyone who claims to know the specific divine meaning of every disaster. Muslims should not say, without revelation, that a particular flood proves Allah was punishing a particular religious community. Such speech can be presumptuous and cruel, especially toward people who have lost family, homes, and livelihoods.
What the Quran actually teaches about disasters
The Quran gives a broader framework. This world is not a simple scoreboard in which safety means divine approval and catastrophe means divine rejection:
"We test you with evil and with good as trial; and to Us you will be returned."
Quran 21:35
"And We will surely test you with something of fear and hunger and a loss of wealth and lives and fruits, but give good tidings to the patient."
Quran 2:155
A calamity may be a test, a warning, a consequence of human actions, a means of expiation for believers, or a punishment. Often, we cannot know which applies to a particular person or event. The Quran does describe past peoples destroyed for grave wrongdoing, but those judgments were known through revelation. They do not give us permission to turn every modern earthquake or flood into a confident verdict.
Why Mecca and Muslim lands are not exceptions
Mecca is sacred, but sacredness does not mean that its buildings and inhabitants are exempt from physical causes, hardship, or death. The Kaaba itself has been damaged and rebuilt throughout history. The 2023 Turkey-Syria earthquake and flooding in Mecca therefore create no contradiction: they show that worldly calamity reaches Muslim populations as well as others.
For believers, suffering can carry spiritual meaning without being evidence that every victim was guilty. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said:
"No fatigue, nor disease, nor sorrow, nor harm, nor distress befalls a Muslim, even if it were the prick he receives from a thorn, but that Allah expiates some of his sins for that."
Sahih al-Bukhari; Sahih Muslim
That promise concerns the believer's reward and purification, not a claim that Muslims will avoid disasters.
What the argument establishes
It establishes that selective claims about disasters are intellectually weak and morally irresponsible. It does not establish that Islam is false. Islam's case rests on revelation, its message, and its evidence, not on guessing the hidden purpose of each catastrophe. The proper response to disaster is compassion, practical help, repentance, and humility before Allah - not triumphalism.