The argument identifies a real passage in Ibn Kathir, but it draws a conclusion that the verse does not support. In the Quran and the law derived from it, disbelief is not itself the same as armed aggression, hirabah, or permission for private individuals to kill.

Why the objection sounds plausible

The strongest form of the argument is this: Ibn Kathir explains "waging war against Allah and His Messenger" in Quran 5:33 as opposing and contradicting them, and some classical explanations use broad language that can include disbelief or rebellion. Since the verse then mentions execution, crucifixion, amputation, and exile, the critic says that an unbeliever is not necessarily an "innocent" person in Islamic law. The protection mentioned in the hadith, it is argued, belongs only to a mu'ahid - someone covered by a treaty or the dhimma - not to non-Muslims generally.

That is a serious claim, but it combines different legal categories and treats a broad theological description as though it were a complete criminal definition.

What Quran 5:33 actually addresses

Quran 5:33 describes those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive to spread corruption in the land. Classical tafsir, including Ibn Kathir, discusses this primarily under the law of hirabah: violent banditry, armed terror, murder, and the forcible seizure of property. The punishments are not a general penalty for holding the wrong belief. The verse itself refers to an active crime - waging war and spreading corruption - not merely to being a non-Muslim.

Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth to spread corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land.

Quran 5:33

A commentator may explain "waging war against Allah" in theological or linguistic terms as opposing His command. That does not mean every person who disbelieves has committed the specific public crime regulated by this verse. Otherwise the Quran's repeated distinction between peaceful unbelievers and aggressors would become meaningless.

The Quran and Sunnah distinguish belief from aggression

The Quran says Muslims may deal kindly and justly with those who do not fight them or expel them from their homes, while reserving a different ruling for those who do fight them. It also commands restraint in war and forbids transgression. Thus "innocent" is a modern shorthand, not a claim that every non-Muslim is religiously correct. It means a person who has not committed a lawful ground of combat.

Allah does not forbid you from being kind and just toward those who have not fought you because of religion and have not expelled you from your homes. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly.

Quran 60:8

Whoever kills a mu'ahid will not smell the fragrance of Paradise, although its fragrance may be detected from the distance of forty years.

Sahih al-Bukhari

A mu'ahid means a non-Muslim granted security by a covenant, treaty, or protection. The hadith shows that such protection is sacred; it does not imply that everyone outside that legal status may be killed by individuals. Classical law still required lawful authority, a recognized state of war, and rules distinguishing combatants from noncombatants. Quran 9:29 concerns a political and military order, not a license for vigilante violence.

Therefore, the objection does not establish that disbelief itself is hirabah or that non-Muslims are generally killable. It shows only that Islamic law recognizes specific wartime and public-security offenses, alongside strong protections for peaceful people, treaty-holders, and those granted safety.