The argument identifies a real question, but it depends on treating abrogation as ordinary social reform. In Islamic theology, abrogation was a feature of revelation while revelation was still being delivered; it was not a principle allowing later generations to rewrite the completed Quran.
Why the objection appears persuasive
The strongest form of the objection is this: society changed during the Prophet's 23 years, and some rulings changed with it. Yet society has changed vastly more over fourteen centuries, while Islamic law is said to remain fixed. Slavery makes the challenge especially serious. The Quran regulates slavery and encourages emancipation, but does not plainly issue a universal abolition command. One may therefore ask whether later abolition resulted mainly from British pressure rather than from Islamic law itself.
Abrogation was not an open-ended revision process
The Quran presents abrogation as occurring within the period of revelation:
"We do not abrogate a verse or cause it to be forgotten except that We bring forth one better than it or similar to it."
Quran 2:106
This describes God's instruction to the first believing community as circumstances unfolded under prophetic guidance. It does not say that later human beings may replace a ruling whenever conditions change. Once revelation was complete, the authority to abrogate ended:
"Today I have perfected for you your religion, completed My favor upon you, and approved for you Islam as a religion."
Quran 5:3
Classical scholars also did not treat every change in application as abrogation. They distinguished between a permanent rule, a specific exception, a condition, custom, public policy, and interpretation. Those tools allow law to address new circumstances without claiming that God has changed His command.
What slavery does and does not show
Here the honest answer matters. Classical Islamic law did not abolish slavery in one universal legal sentence. It accepted a premodern institution connected to warfare, while placing restrictions on it, forbidding the enslavement of free people, encouraging emancipation, and making freeing slaves an expiation for certain sins. That is morally significant, but it is not the same as abolition.
Nor is it historically accurate to reduce modern abolition to a single cause. European pressure played a major role in many Muslim lands, but Muslim scholars, rulers, reformers, treaties, and changing political conditions also contributed. Contemporary enslavement cannot simply be revived by individuals: kidnapping and trafficking are forbidden, modern states have binding agreements, and legitimate authorities may prohibit a once-permitted practice when its lawful conditions no longer exist. The Quran commands fulfillment of contracts:
"O you who believe, fulfill the contracts."
Quran 5:1
The precise conclusion
The objection does establish that slavery requires a candid moral and legal discussion; pretending that classical law explicitly abolished it weakens the case. But it does not establish a contradiction between abrogation and finality. Abrogation belonged to the completion of revelation, while later law can still use interpretation, conditions, treaties, and public authority. The question is not whether Muslims may rewrite revelation, but how enduring principles are applied responsibly after revelation has ended.