Radiocarbon dating does not date the Quranic ink or prove when the words were written. It dates the animal skin, and the reported ranges include dates after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was born; therefore, these findings do not place the Quran before him.
What the dating claim actually says
The strongest form of the objection is reasonable: some parchment associated with the Sana'a manuscripts has been radiocarbon-dated to a range beginning before 570 CE, and the Birmingham folios have often been reported within a range such as 568-645 CE. If one treats the earliest date as the writing date, the conclusion seems unavoidable: Quranic text existed before Muhammad (PBUH).
But that is not what the laboratory result says. Radiocarbon dating estimates when the animal from which the parchment was made died, with a calibrated probability range. It does not identify the date on which the hide was processed, stored, written upon, or recopied. A parchment dated within 568-645 may have been written in 610, 630, or later. The lower boundary is not a claim that the manuscript was written on that date.
Skin is not ink
This distinction is decisive. The parchment is an organic material and can be tested by radiocarbon methods. The writing is a separate historical layer. Carbon ink is generally made from soot or charcoal and is not dated by the same test in these investigations. Parchment could also have been kept for some time before use, although a long delay need not be proposed to answer the objection.
Other evidence, including script style, manuscript structure, and the distinction between the upper and lower writing in a palimpsest, is used to estimate when the writing was produced. Such evidence may place a manuscript very early, but "early" is not the same as "before Muhammad (PBUH)." In the case of the Birmingham folios, the range includes the Prophet's lifetime and the period immediately following it. The result is therefore compatible with an early Islamic manuscript, not evidence of a pre-prophetic Quran.
How this fits the transmission history
The Quran was recited and written during the Prophet's ministry, then gathered into a codex after his death. This is described in an authentic report:
"So Abu Bakr ordered me to collect the Quran. I began to collect it from palm stalks, thin white stones, and from the memories of men."
Sahih al-Bukhari
That report does not require every surviving leaf to have been written immediately after a verse was revealed. Nor does a parchment's age establish what text it originally carried. A manuscript can preserve text written shortly after the Prophet's time on skin that had been prepared earlier.
Thus, the dating establishes that very early Quranic manuscripts exist and that some parchment may predate 570 CE. It does not establish that the Quranic writing predates Muhammad (PBUH), that the text existed before revelation, or that the traditional account is undermined. The claim confuses the age of the material with the age of the writing upon it.