The similarities between Mesopotamian stories and later biblical and Quranic accounts deserve serious examination, but they do not establish that the Quran borrowed its prophets from Sumerian myths. At most, they show that ancient peoples preserved overlapping memories and themes; dependence requires much stronger evidence than resemblance.
Why the borrowing argument seems plausible
The argument has a reasonable starting point. Sumerian and Akkadian texts are older than the Quran and contain antediluvian kings, extraordinary lifespans, a devastating flood, a chosen survivor, and stories involving ascent to the heavens. The Sumerian King List also places several rulers before the flood, while Genesis places Adam's descendants before Noah. Since the Quran presents Adam, Idris, and Noah as real human beings and prophets, a critic may argue that Islam simply reworked older Mesopotamian traditions.
There are also broad parallels between the flood of Ziusudra, Atrahasis, and Gilgamesh and the flood of Noah. Likewise, the ascent of the Mesopotamian king Etana is sometimes compared with the Quranic statement about Idris. These parallels make literary influence a question worth asking, not a question that should be dismissed without examination.
What the evidence actually shows
The central difficulty is that the alleged correspondences are much weaker than the argument suggests. The Sumerian antediluvian kings are rulers with different names and lists from the biblical patriarchs. The Quran does not reproduce the Sumerian King List, the Genesis genealogy, or the Mesopotamian royal ideology. It does not even give a continuous genealogy from Adam to Noah.
The flood motif is widespread among ancient peoples. A shared motif can result from borrowing, common cultural memory, or independent reflection on a memorable catastrophe. To demonstrate dependence, one needs distinctive verbal or structural parallels and a plausible route of transmission. No such direct textual dependence between the Quran and the Sumerian tablets has been established. Similarities in names are especially uncertain when the languages, spellings, and meanings differ.
The Quran also reshapes the moral meaning of these accounts. Noah is not a semi-divine king seeking personal immortality. He is a messenger calling his people to worship God, and the flood is connected with persistent rejection of that call. The Quran even emphasizes that family status cannot replace faith when Noah's unbelieving son is lost.
And We certainly sent Noah to his people, and he said, "Indeed, I am to you a clear warner: that you worship none but Allah."
Quran 11:25-26
What the Quran claims about earlier traditions
Islam does not claim that every ancient religious story began with the Quran. It claims that God sent guidance to earlier peoples, while human communities preserved some truths, altered others, and surrounded them with legend. Thus, similarities with earlier material are compatible with revelation; they are not automatically evidence against it.
He has revealed to you the Book in truth, confirming what came before it, and He revealed the Torah and the Gospel.
Quran 3:3
The same principle applies to Idris. The Quran says only that he was a truthful prophet whom God raised to a high station; it does not narrate Etana's story or depend on its details.
Therefore, the comparisons establish that the Quran speaks about themes known in the ancient Near East. They do not establish that Muhammad (PBUH) copied Sumerian texts, nor that Adam, Noah, and Idris were invented from Sumerian kings. The borrowing thesis remains a possibility asserted by the critic, not a conclusion demonstrated by the evidence.