The wording of Quran 54:1-2 can be read as pointing to a future event in principle, since Arabic sometimes uses the past tense for a certain future event. But the surrounding evidence, especially the authentic reports from the Companions, strongly indicates that the verses also refer to a real splitting of the moon witnessed in Mecca.
Why the future-event reading is possible
The argument should not be dismissed simply because the verb is in the past tense. Arabic can use a past form for a future event when its occurrence is presented as certain. The Quran itself does this in descriptions of the Day of Resurrection, such as "The command of Allah has come," even though the final judgment had not yet occurred when the verse was revealed.
The Hour has drawn near, and the moon has split. Yet whenever they see a sign, they turn away and say, "Persistent magic."
Quran 54:1-2
On this reading, the passage could describe an end-times sign whose certainty is expressed through the past tense. The statement about people calling it magic would then describe the reaction of future rejecters, not necessarily an incident in Mecca. Grammar by itself does not force a historical interpretation.
What the immediate context points toward
Still, the context reads more naturally as a sign already shown to the audience. The verses speak of people seeing a sign, turning away, and calling it magic. The following verses recall earlier peoples who rejected messengers despite clear warnings. The passage functions as a warning to the Meccans: a sign has been shown, yet their response is the same as that of earlier disbelieving nations.
This is how the major early commentators generally understood it. They treated the splitting as a miracle granted during the Prophet's (PBUH) lifetime, not merely as an event reserved for the end of time. The past tense is therefore not an obstacle; it agrees with the historical reading and does not require a special future-tense explanation.
The strongest evidence from the Sunnah
The historical interpretation is not based on grammar alone. Several authentic reports state that the moon split during the Prophet's (PBUH) lifetime. One report from Ibn Masud describes the people seeing the moon in two parts, with the mountain appearing between them. Similar reports are recorded from other Companions in both Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim.
The moon was split during the time of the Messenger of Allah (PBUH), and they saw it in two parts.
Sahih al-Bukhari; Sahih Muslim, reports from Ibn Masud and others
These reports explain how the first hearers understood Quran 54:1-2, and they were accepted by the mainstream classical scholars. A person may still argue that the verse could have an additional future reference, or that its wording permits that possibility. But the claim that it refers exclusively to a future event conflicts with the strongest transmitted explanation of the passage.
So the proposed reading establishes a legitimate linguistic possibility, not a decisive interpretation. It does not overturn the historical miracle reported in authentic Sunnah and affirmed by the early scholars.