The examples concern the early Arabic writing system, known as the Quranic rasm, not a changing Quranic wording. They show that the same Arabic word could be written with or without certain mater lectionis letters, while its pronunciation and transmitted text remained fixed.

Why the objection sounds serious

The criticism has a real point if preservation is defined as requiring every written word to follow one modern spelling. The Quran writes Ibrahim in more than one form, al-Rahman without the expected alif, and bism in the basmala without the alif found in the ordinary spelling of ism. Some classical discussions also explain omissions such as these by reference to frequent usage, economy of writing, or established scribal practice.

On that reading, Muslims did not preserve a divine manuscript letter for letter; they adjusted its written form for human convenience. The objection becomes especially forceful against the claim that the Quran's present visual spelling was dictated in precisely the same way as its recitation.

Writing a word is not the same as changing its recitation

Early Arabic did not represent every long vowel with the consistent spelling used in modern Arabic. It also commonly lacked dots and vowel marks. A word could therefore have different written shapes while remaining the same word when read aloud. The omission of an alif in bism does not make the reader pronounce it differently, just as an abbreviation in another language does not create a new spoken sentence.

The Quran itself describes preservation primarily in terms of revelation, memorization, and guided recitation:

"Indeed, We have sent down the Reminder, and indeed We will preserve it."

Quran 15:9

"Move not your tongue with it to hasten it. Indeed, upon Us is its collection and its recitation."

Quran 75:16-17

The written rasm was one essential means of preservation, but it was not the sole carrier of the text. From the beginning, the Quran was learned orally from the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), taught by reciters, and checked against written copies. The standard written copies produced under Uthman preserved the consonantal framework that could accommodate the authenticated modes of recitation, rather than inventing a new wording.

What the early sources actually establish

The Prophet (PBUH) said:

"The Quran was revealed in seven ahruf, so recite whichever of them is easy for you."

Sahih al-Bukhari; Sahih Muslim

This does not mean that scribes were free to edit the Quran. It means that revelation itself included permitted recitational forms, while the companions transmitted and regulated them. Classical scholars did differ over whether every detail of the rasm was divinely specified or whether some features reflected the companions' writing conventions. That is a discussion about the status of orthography, not evidence that passages were lost or rewritten.

What this does and does not prove

It does disprove an overly simple claim that every modern-looking spelling feature was independently revealed and that no orthographic convention ever existed. It does not show that Muslims changed the Quran's words, meanings, or accepted recitations for convenience. The alleged "alterations" are stable spelling conventions within an overwhelmingly continuous oral and written transmission. Thus the examples challenge a simplistic definition of preservation, but they do not establish textual corruption.