The objection is strong against a religion that asks for belief in an afterlife with no reasons beyond the promise itself. But it does not show that the afterlife is irrational; it confuses "not directly testable in a laboratory" with "without evidence," and it also reduces religion to only one of its aims.
What the objection gets right
The strongest form of the argument is this: nobody can presently observe Paradise or Hell, and the dead do not return as publicly repeatable witnesses. If a claim is framed so that no possible experience could count against it, then it cannot be established by ordinary empirical testing. A person should not accept an unlimited promise merely because it is comforting.
Islam does not require us to pretend that the unseen is directly observable. The Quran itself distinguishes between what is seen and what is unseen, and it condemns careless belief:
And do not pursue that of which you have no knowledge. Indeed, the hearing, the sight and the heart - about all those one will be questioned.
Quran 17:36
Unseen does not mean unsupported
Falsifiability is useful for some scientific hypotheses, but it is not the measure of every rational belief. We do not test a historical event by recreating it, nor do we place logic, moral truths, or other minds in a laboratory. We assess such matters through evidence, explanation, testimony, and inference.
The Islamic case is cumulative. It includes the Quran's message and language, its account of reality, the character and prophethood of Muhammad (PBUH), the preservation and public transmission of revelation, and the way its teachings explain human moral experience. None of these is a photograph of the next life. Together, however, they can provide rational grounds for trusting the One who tells us about it.
The Quran repeatedly presents belief as reasoned rather than blind:
Or were they created by nothing, or were they the creators [of themselves]? Or did they create the heavens and the earth? Rather, they are not certain.
Quran 52:35-36
Religion is not only an after-death payoff
The premise that religion's "entire payoff" lies after death is also inaccurate. Islam teaches worship, repentance, moral discipline, mercy, justice, family responsibilities, and a truthful way of understanding life now. These do not prove Paradise, but they show that religion makes present-world claims and has present-world consequences.
At the same time, Islam does not say that earthly benefit is the final test. Faith includes trust in realities beyond direct perception:
This is the Book about which there is no doubt, a guidance for those conscious of Allah - those who believe in the unseen, establish prayer, and spend out of what We have provided for them.
Quran 2:2-3
So the argument establishes a limit: the afterlife cannot be verified by ordinary observation before resurrection. It does not establish that belief is irrational, false, or without evidence. It shows instead that the question must be judged through the wider case for revelation, not by demanding a kind of test that an unseen future reality cannot provide.