The two examples do not establish a contradiction between the Quran and authentic Sunnah. One concerns differing reports whose wording and classification must be examined; the other concerns a Prophetic exception and explanation of a Quranic prohibition, not a reversal of it.

What the objection fairly points out

The objection has real force if every report called "sahih" is treated as equally certain, identical in wording, and independent of interpretation. One report is commonly quoted as saying that the Muslim community will divide into 72 sects, while another says 73. Likewise, the Quran forbids carrion and blood, whereas a hadith permits fish, locusts, liver, and spleen. At first sight, that looks like revelation contradicting revelation.

But that argument moves too quickly. Hadith criticism does not say that every circulating wording is authentic. Nor does "sahih" mean that every report has the same level of certainty as the Quran's mass-transmitted text.

The numbers 72 and 73

The well-known versions recorded by Abu Dawud and al-Tirmidhi say that the Jews divided into 71 groups, the Christians into 72, and this community into 73. The report often cited for "72 Muslim sects" may involve a different wording, a disputed route, or a way of counting that excludes the saved group. Scholars therefore examined the chains and meanings rather than declaring the entire subject a contradiction.

The Jews split into seventy-one sects, and the Christians split into seventy-two sects. This community will split into seventy-three sects.

Sunan Abi Dawud 4596; Jami' at-Tirmidhi 2640

Even where scholars accept more than one wording, a numerical variation in transmitted reports does not prove that the Prophet (PBUH) contradicted himself. It first raises a hadith-critical question: which wording is established, and how should the reports be reconciled? The numbers are not a foundation of creed, and they do not license declaring particular Muslims outside Islam merely because of a label.

Why the food ruling is not a contradiction

The hadith about fish, locusts, liver, and spleen describes exceptions to the general rule. The Quran itself commands believers to follow the Prophet's explanation:

We revealed to you the Reminder so that you may explain to people what has been revealed to them.

Quran 16:44

Moreover, the Quran specifies "blood poured forth" in its discussion of prohibited food (Quran 6:145). Liver and spleen are blood-containing organs, but they are not flowing blood in the legal sense. The Prophet's ruling therefore clarifies the scope of the prohibition; it does not permit blood that the Quran forbids. The report states:

Two dead animals and two kinds of blood have been permitted for us: the fish and the locust, and the liver and the spleen.

Sunan Ibn Majah 3314

What this does and does not establish

These examples may justify asking careful questions about transmission and interpretation. They do not show that authentic Sunnah conflicts with the Quran. They show why Muslim scholars distinguish the Quran from hadith in transmission, authenticate reports individually, and read Prophetic rulings together with the Quran's language and principles.