The objection is correct about one important limit: an argument from the universe's beginning or fine-tuning does not, by itself, identify the Creator as the God of the Quran. But this does not make such arguments irrelevant to Islam; they establish part of the rational foundation, while revelation identifies the Creator and supplies reasons for trusting that revelation.
What the argument establishes
The strongest version of the objection says that several religions can agree that the universe has a cause or designer while disagreeing about that being's nature. A first cause might be called the God of the Bible, a deity from another tradition, or an impersonal principle. Therefore, the argument does not logically entail Islam in isolation.
That criticism is fair. Cosmological and fine-tuning arguments are not complete proofs of every Islamic doctrine. They do not, by themselves, establish the Quran, prophethood, prayer, or the details of the afterlife. Muslims should not claim more than the argument gives.
Were they created by nothing, or were they themselves the creators? Or did they create the heavens and the earth? Rather, they have no certainty.
Quran 52:35-36
This is a powerful question about dependence and ultimate explanation, but it is not presented as the entire case for Islam.
Why a cause is not just any deity
Once one argues that the universe is contingent and caused, the proposed cause cannot simply be another limited object within the universe. It must be independent, uncaused, and not subject to the physical conditions it brings into existence. Fine-tuning likewise points, if it points to agency, toward intelligence rather than a blind force.
These conclusions fit the Quran's conception of God with unusual precision: one Creator, not a collection of competing gods; independent of creation; unlike created things; and not part of a material genealogy.
Say, "He is Allah - One. Allah, the Eternal Refuge. He neither begets nor is born, nor is there any equivalent to Him."
Quran 112:1-4
The Quran also gives a direct argument against rival divine beings:
Had there been in the heavens and earth gods besides Allah, both would have been ruined.
Quran 21:22
So the evidence for a Creator does not identify Islam by a single syllogism. It narrows the possibilities, and Islam then offers a coherent account of that Creator's unity, transcendence, purpose, and relation to humanity.
How Islam is identified
The further question is whether the Quran is genuinely revelation and whether Muhammad (PBUH) was a true prophet. That involves historical and textual evidence, the Quran's message and literary character, its consistent call to pure monotheism, and the Prophet's (PBUH) life and claims. Those matters should be examined separately, rather than demanded from a cosmological argument.
Rival religions appealing to the same universe do not make all interpretations equally credible. They must be compared by their doctrines, evidence, internal consistency, and ability to explain the world. The scientific arguments establish that belief in a Creator is rationally serious; revelation and the case for prophethood explain why that Creator is the God of the Quran.
Plainly: these arguments do not prove Islam alone. They do, however, support a necessary foundation of Islamic belief and can form part of a cumulative case that Islam best identifies and describes the Creator.