Knowing that Allah exists is not the same as possessing iman. Islam joins inward recognition to truthful affirmation, submission, and worship; therefore, a person may acknowledge Allah while still rejecting His right to be worshipped or knowingly refusing His command.
The strongest form of the argument
The argument has a real point: disbelief is not always simple ignorance. Many people who rejected the messengers understood their message and recognized that Allah is the Creator. If faith meant only awareness of Allah's existence, then such people could not be called disbelievers. Likewise, a Muslim who falls into a grave act of disbelief might say, "I still know that Allah is real." That shows that knowledge alone cannot explain the whole meaning of faith.
This objection rightly exposes a shallow definition of kufr as mere lack of information. The Quran itself says that some people rejected what they inwardly recognized:
"They rejected them, although they were convinced in their hearts, wrongfully and arrogantly."
Quran 27:14
What the Quran means by knowing Allah
The Quran distinguishes recognition of Allah from sincere faith and worship. When the pagan Arabs were asked who created the heavens and the earth, they would answer, "Allah." Yet they still worshipped others alongside Him:
"If you ask them who created the heavens and the earth, they will surely say, 'Allah.' Say, 'All praise is for Allah!' But most of them do not know."
Quran 31:25
Their admission was a kind of knowledge, but it did not make them Muslims. They refused the consequence of that knowledge: directing worship to Allah alone and submitting to His Messenger. The Quran also says that their belief was mixed with shirk:
"And most of them do not believe in Allah without associating others with Him."
Quran 12:106
Iblis is an even clearer example. He knew Allah, spoke to Him, and knew that the command came from his Lord. Yet he became a disbeliever through arrogant refusal and disobedience. The Quran describes his rejection of the command to prostrate before Adam as kufr (Quran 2:34).
Faith includes submission, not information alone
In the language of revelation, iman includes the heart's acceptance, the tongue's affirmation, and the limbs' submission. This does not mean that every sin makes a Muslim a disbeliever. Major sins normally make a person sinful, not an apostate, unless the person denies an established obligation, mocks revelation, worships other than Allah, or performs another act that is clearly kufr while understanding and intending its meaning.
Judging a particular person also requires care: coercion, ignorance, misunderstanding, and lack of intent can affect the ruling. But the principle is plain. Knowledge may establish the evidence against someone; it does not itself constitute faith.
Thus, the argument refutes the idea that disbelief is mere ignorance, but it does not establish that no Muslim can apostatize. A person can know Allah's existence and still reject His exclusive worship, His revelation, or His command. Saving faith is knowledge joined to willing submission.