The viral claim is not entirely invented, but it is usually presented with far more certainty than the evidence allows. Some premodern legal discussions permitted limited sexual enjoyment within a marriage involving a prepubescent girl, while forbidding penetration or anything causing harm; this is not the same as a general Islamic fatwa permitting sexual abuse of infants.

What the polemic is drawing on

Classical jurists generally accepted marriage contracts involving minors, reflecting the social and legal world in which they wrote. Within that framework, some manuals discussed what a husband might do with a wife who was too young for intercourse. Terms such as istimta' (sexual enjoyment) or tafkhidh (stimulation between the thighs) are sometimes translated in online arguments as "thighing."

So the strongest version of the objection is this: certain recognized jurists did not treat every non-penetrative sexual act with a prepubescent wife as automatically unlawful. That is a real feature of parts of premodern fiqh, and it should not be denied or hidden.

What the Quranic evidence actually establishes

Quran 65:4 is often cited because it gives the waiting period for divorced women "who have not menstruated." Classical commentators commonly understood this to include prepubescent girls. But the verse regulates divorce and waiting periods; it does not command marriage to children or grant permission for sexual acts with infants.

And test the orphans until they reach marriageable age. Then, if you perceive in them sound judgment, release their property to them.

Quran 4:6

This verse does not settle every historical rule about marriage, but it shows that the Quran connects adult responsibility with maturity and sound judgment. It is not evidence for sexual access to babies.

How the legal ruling must be understood

A passage in a fiqh manual is not automatically a universally binding fatwa. Its attribution, wording, context, and school must be checked. Viral quotations frequently omit whether the text is discussing a legally married wife, a particular age, the ability to endure an act, or a prohibition of harm. They also often give no reliable book, edition, or page, making confident attribution impossible.

Even in classical law, the principle of preventing harm is fundamental:

There should be neither harming nor reciprocating harm.

Reported in Ibn Majah and transmitted in al-Muwatta

Sexual contact that harms a child is therefore forbidden by the general principles of Islamic law, regardless of a narrow technical discussion in an old manual. Contemporary Muslim authorities and the laws of Muslim-majority countries commonly set enforceable minimum ages and prohibit child abuse.

Thus, the claim establishes that some premodern jurists held permissive positions concerning limited acts with a minor wife. It does not establish that Islam has a single fatwa endorsing sexual use of infants, that such an act is a Quranic teaching, or that every Muslim school and authority accepts it. The historical material deserves honest criticism, but the meme is not a fair summary of it.