The objection has force only if the earlier passages unambiguously teach that God became a human being and that Jesus is divine. Islam denies that conclusion, while affirming that Muhammad (PBUH) came to restore the prophets' central message: worship the one Creator, not a creature.

What the objection is actually claiming

The argument is straightforward. Genesis says that the Lord appeared to Abraham, Isaiah gives a child the name "Mighty God," and John presents Jesus as God's unique Son given for the world. If these texts teach God's appearance in human form and Jesus' divine sonship, then the Quran seems to contradict earlier revelation when it rejects incarnation and condemns the claim that Jesus is the son of Allah.

That is a serious argument, and it should not be answered by pretending that Christians do not find these passages significant. The real question is whether they establish the doctrine being attributed to them, and whether "confirming" earlier revelation means endorsing every later interpretation and textual form.

What the passages do and do not establish

Genesis 18 describes the Lord appearing to Abraham, yet it also describes three men, and the chapter moves between singular and plural language. Jewish and Christian interpreters have understood this passage in different ways: as a divine manifestation, an appearance through angels, or a literary presentation of God's message. It does not plainly state that God permanently became a man, was born, or assumed human limitations.

Isaiah 9:6 is likewise a disputed prophetic text in translation and interpretation. Its royal titles are exalted, but a title applied to a promised ruler does not by itself explain whether the ruler is God incarnate. John 3:16 clearly teaches John's theology of Jesus as God's unique Son. Muslims respect Jesus, but do not accept that a theological title proves that the eternal Creator became one of His creatures. In biblical language, "son of God" can also be used in a representative or covenantal sense; the decisive question is how the term is defined.

The Quran's account of continuity

The Messiah, son of Mary, was only a messenger of Allah, and his mother was a woman of truth. They both ate food.

Quran 5:75

The point is not that Jesus was ordinary. The Quran affirms his virgin birth, miracles by God's permission, messiahship, and unique honor. But dependence, birth, eating, and human need are signs of creaturehood, not qualities of the Creator.

The Jews say, "Ezra is the son of Allah," and the Christians say, "The Messiah is the son of Allah." That is a statement from their mouths. They imitate the saying of those who disbelieved before. May Allah condemn them; how are they deluded?

Quran 9:30

Thus the Quran's test is continuity with the original prophetic call to uncompromising monotheism, not agreement with every later reading of scripture. It does establish a real disagreement between Islam and orthodox Christian doctrine. It does not establish that Muhammad (PBUH) taught a different God; it establishes that he rejected attributing incarnation and divine sonship to the one God.