The absence of a surviving manuscript personally sent by Uthman does not disprove the early standardization of the Quran. It does mean that the Topkapi and Samarkand manuscripts should not be presented as proven originals of Uthman's codices.
The argument in its strongest form
The objection is reasonable as a historical question. The traditional account says that Uthman ordered an authorized recension, had several copies prepared, and sent them to major Muslim centers, often described as five cities, with reciters. Yet no manuscript can be securely traced to one of those dispatched copies. The Topkapi and Samarkand codices, frequently marketed as "Uthman's Quran," are dated by many manuscript specialists to later in the seventh or eighth century, or to a range that does not establish Uthmanic ownership. The Topkapi manuscript is incomplete, its script and readings require careful analysis, and claims that it differs from the Cairo edition by thousands of places sound, at first, like evidence of substantial textual change.
What the early account actually claims
The reports do not claim that Uthman produced a single luxury manuscript that would be preserved forever. They describe the creation and distribution of working exemplars, generally written in the early Arabic consonantal script. The reports also differ in the number of copies and destinations; "five cities" is not a universally fixed detail.
Uthman said to the three Qurashi men among the scribes: "If you differ with Zayd ibn Thabit on any point of the Quran, write it in the dialect of Quraysh, for it was revealed in their tongue." Then he sent copies to the various regions.
Sahih al-Bukhari, Book of the Virtues of the Quran
A dispatched exemplar could be copied, worn out, replaced, damaged in war, or discarded when a later manuscript became available. The loss of all named originals is therefore unsurprising over fourteen centuries. Manuscript survival is not a controlled experiment: famous works often survive only through later copies, while ordinary documents disappear.
What the manuscripts can and cannot show
The Topkapi manuscript is not securely Uthman's personal copy, and the Samarkand manuscript cannot responsibly be used as a proven autograph either. Their value is different. Their early consonantal text, together with other Quranic manuscripts, inscriptions, and early quotations, shows that a substantially stable Quranic text existed very early. But neither manuscript by itself proves the entire later transmission story.
Nor does a count of "over 2,000 differences" automatically mean 2,000 changed verses. Such counts may include spelling conventions, omitted or added vowel marks, word division, scribal corrections, variant verse numbering, and readings represented by the same consonantal skeleton. The Cairo edition also includes a particular reading tradition and modern punctuation and numbering; it is not a photograph of Uthman's sheets. Genuine questions about early readings deserve examination, but they must be classified rather than counted indiscriminately.
Thus the evidence does not prove that Topkapi or Samarkand is Uthman's original. It does show that the standardization account is compatible with the manuscript record, while the record independently supports very early textual stability. The faith claim ultimately rests on the whole transmission, not on one museum exhibit.