The expression "Satanic Verses" is not a Quranic expression. It is an English label for disputed reports found in some early tafsir, history, and sira works, usually connected with the story of the gharaniq. These reports allege that the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), while reciting Surat al-Najm, uttered words praising al-Lat, al-Uzza, and Manat, three idols worshipped by the pagan Arabs. The alleged words are not part of the Quran or any established Quranic reading. What is authentically established is that the Prophet (PBUH) recited Surat al-Najm and prostrated, and that some of those present prostrated with him.

Two questions must be kept separate. First, do early historical reports about such an incident exist, and how strong are they? Second, were the alleged words ever part of the Quran? The answer to the second question is certain: they are not part of the Quran. The first question requires examination of the reports, their chains, and their wording.

What is the allegation?

The most familiar version claims that, after reciting the verses mentioning al-Lat, al-Uzza, and Manat, the Prophet (PBUH) allegedly added words to the effect of: "These are the exalted gharaniq, and indeed their intercession is hoped for." One commonly quoted wording is:

تلك الغرانيق العلى وإن شفاعتهن لترتجى

Tilka al-gharaniq al-ula, wa inna shafaatuhunna la turtaja.

This sentence is not part of the Quran. It appears in disputed historical reports, not in a report whose chain and wording are accepted as sound without serious dispute. The reports do not preserve one uniform wording, and they differ over important details.

In Arabic, gharaniq can refer to a type of water bird and, in some usage, to a handsome or exalted being. In the context of this story, those who accept the report understand the expression as a euphemistic reference to the three idols and as an affirmation that their intercession was hoped for. That interpretation belongs to the disputed story; it is not a meaning supplied by the Quranic text.

Some versions say that Satan cast words into the Prophet's (PBUH) recitation or onto his tongue. Other versions differ over the words allegedly spoken and over what happened afterward. Explanations involving confusion, misunderstanding, or the listeners' mistaken interpretation are interpretations of particular reports. They should not be presented as the wording of an authenticated hadith unless the relevant report itself establishes them.

The alleged words are absent from the transmitted Quranic text and from the established Quranic readings. The Quran is established through widespread, continuous transmission known as tawatur, not through an isolated report preserved in a tafsir or history work. An isolated historical report cannot add a sentence to the Quran.

This point should be stated precisely: the absence of the sentence from the Quran proves that it is not a Quranic verse. It does not, by itself, settle the separate historical question of whether someone may have uttered similar non-Quranic words during an occasion of recitation. That question must be assessed through the chains and texts of the reports. Those reports are disputed, and no version provides an undisputed, sound proof that the famous wording was part of the Prophet's (PBUH) Quranic recitation.

What is authentically established?

Sahih al-Bukhari records the recitation of Surat al-Najm and the resulting prostration. The authentic reports cited here do not mention any satanic addition, praise of idols, or later correction by Jibril of an idol-praising recitation.

Abdullah ibn Masud reported that the Prophet (PBUH) recited Surat al-Najm and prostrated, and those who were present prostrated with him, except an old man who took a handful of pebbles or dust, raised it to his forehead, and said, "This is enough for me." Ibn Masud added, "I later saw him killed as a disbeliever."

Sahih al-Bukhari 4863

Ibn Abbas reported that the Prophet (PBUH) prostrated while reciting Surat al-Najm, and with him prostrated the Muslims, the polytheists, the jinn, and human beings.

Sahih al-Bukhari 4862

These sahih reports establish the recitation and the prostration. Their omission of the alleged story is not, by itself, conclusive proof against every detail of every other report, since a hadith may report only the part relevant to its subject. However, these reports provide no support for the alleged addition and cannot authenticate a story they do not contain.

The prostration of the Muslims is directly consistent with the conclusion of the surah, which commands prostration to Allah. The report that polytheists also prostrated does not specify why they did so. It does not identify an idol-praising sentence as the cause, and it cannot be used to insert such a sentence into the account.

The sound conclusion from these reports is therefore:

  • The Prophet (PBUH) recited Surat al-Najm and prostrated.
  • Some or all of those present prostrated with him, including polytheists according to the report of Ibn Abbas.
  • The alleged words praising the idols are not found in these authentic reports.
  • Nothing in these reports makes the alleged words part of the Quran.

What does Surat al-Najm actually say?

The transmitted Quranic text does not endorse the idols. After naming al-Lat, al-Uzza, and Manat, it rejects them as names without divine authority:

Have you considered al-Lat and al-Uzza, and Manat, the third - the other one? Is the male for you and for Him the female? That, then, is an unjust division. They are nothing but names you have named - you and your fathers - for which Allah has sent down no authority. They follow nothing but assumption and what their souls desire, although guidance has already come to them from their Lord.

Quran 53:19-23

Near the beginning of the same surah, Allah affirms the truthfulness of the revelation conveyed by the Prophet (PBUH):

Your companion has neither strayed nor erred, nor does he speak from his own inclination. It is only revelation revealed.

Quran 53:2-4

In its immediate context, this passage concerns the Prophet's (PBUH) conveyance of revelation and religious guidance. It should not be stretched into the claim that every ordinary statement he made was itself Quranic revelation. At the same time, it is entirely consistent with the Quran's presentation of his faithful conveyance of revelation and provides no basis for inserting an idol-praising sentence into the Quran.

The surah also places intercession under Allah's authority, even in the case of angels:

And how many angels there are in the heavens whose intercession will not avail at all except after Allah permits for whom He wills and approves.

Quran 53:26

It ends with the command to prostrate to Allah:

So prostrate to Allah and worship.

Quran 53:62

Thus, the surah rejects the idols, gives them no divine authority, presents even angelic intercession as dependent on Allah's permission, and concludes by commanding prostration to Allah. This context does not by itself determine the grading of a historical report, but it is incompatible with treating the alleged sentence as a Quranic affirmation of idol worship.

Why does the story appear in early books?

Versions of the story do appear in early works of tafsir, history, and sira, including works that preserve reports with isnads. This should be acknowledged honestly. The presence of a narration in an early book is not, by itself, a judgment that it is authentic. Reports must be assessed according to their chains, wording, and consistency with stronger evidence.

Al-Tabari, for example, transmitted several versions of the account in his tafsir. His inclusion of a report does not mean that every report he records is sahih. His works preserve a large body of transmitted material for examination, and the reports he cites are not all of one grade.

Classical scholars did not assess the reports in exactly the same way. Al-Bayhaqi judged the story unestablished by reliable transmission, and Ibn Kathir pointed out that important routes were mursal or disconnected. Ibn Hajar discussed the multiplicity of the routes and treated it as potentially relevant to whether the reports had a general historical basis, while still recognizing weakness or interruption in individual routes. This does not make the exact sentence an unquestionable Quranic text or an agreed-upon authentic hadith.

It is therefore imprecise to claim that every route has exactly the same defect. Some reports are mursal, while other routes are presented as connected to a Companion but remain disputed because of their transmitters, their connection, or their wording. The existence of a route that appears connected does not end the hadith-critical dispute.

These are different judgments about the possible historical basis of reports, not different versions of the Quran. A scholar may consider that some early incident lay behind the reports without authenticating the exact sentence as Quran or establishing a report whose chain and wording are beyond serious dispute. Circulation is not authentication.

What is disputed about the chains of narration?

1. Many principal routes are mursal or otherwise disputed

Several well-known versions come through Successors who describe an early Makkan event without naming the Companion from whom they received the information. Such a report is mursal: the Successor attributes the report directly to the Prophet (PBUH), leaving the link between the Successor and the Prophet, normally through a Companion, unstated.

Hadith scholars differed over the evidentiary value of mursal reports. Some gave particular mursal reports weight when supported by independent evidence and other conditions. But a mursal report, especially when its supporting routes are also disputed, is not by itself an undisputed proof for a claim of this magnitude. Other routes connected to the story have also been examined for weakness, disconnection, or hidden defects.

2. Attributions to Ibn Abbas do not settle the matter

Some story-specific versions are attributed to Ibn Abbas or transmitted through routes associated with him. This is not the same as the authentic report in Sahih al-Bukhari that Ibn Abbas reported the prostration. An attribution to a Companion must still be established through a reliable chain.

Some reports attributed to Ibn Abbas are statements of tafsir concerning Quran 22:52 rather than eyewitness accounts of the event. In the relevant material, the routes and their forms are disputed. Some are disconnected, some contain additional material not found in other versions, and the reliability or connection of particular routes has been debated.

A report ending with Ibn Abbas cannot automatically be treated as a marfu report from the Prophet (PBUH). Some categories of Companion statements may be given marfu force under specific conditions, but those conditions cannot simply be assumed here. Even an explicit attribution to the Prophet (PBUH) must be assessed through its chain.

The correct conclusion is that the reports attributed to Ibn Abbas do not provide an undisputed basis for claiming that the Prophet (PBUH) uttered the alleged words as part of his Quranic recitation.

3. The versions differ over the central details

The transmitted reports and later explanations differ over whether Satan placed words in the Prophet's (PBUH) recitation, caused confusion in what was heard, or led the idolaters to misunderstand what was recited. They also differ in wording and in the account of how the matter was followed up.

Variation in historical reports does not, by itself, prove that every element is false. But when the disputed details concern the exact words allegedly recited as Quran, such variation reinforces the need for a sound isnad and a coherent matn. The reports do not establish the alleged sentence with an undisputed chain and text.

4. The authentic narration contains no such words

The authentic reports cited above say that the Prophet (PBUH) recited Surat al-Najm and that listeners prostrated. They do not say that he praised idols, that Satan inserted words into the Quran, or that Jibril later corrected the recitation. These hadiths cannot be used to authenticate an additional story that they do not contain.

Does Quran 22:52 prove the story?

Quran 22:52 is sometimes cited as proof of the allegation. On one classical interpretation, which understands tamanna in a recitation-related sense, it may be translated:

Never did We send before you any messenger or prophet except that, when he recited, Satan cast something into his recitation. But Allah abolishes what Satan casts, then Allah makes His verses firm. And Allah is Knowing and Wise.

Quran 22:52

The wording reflects a genuine interpretive issue. The root of tamanna commonly conveys wishing or desiring, while some early exegetes understood it here in a recitation-related sense. The rendering "when he recited" is therefore an interpretation of the verse, not a separate Quranic reading.

Even on the recitation-based interpretation, the verse says that Allah abolishes what Satan casts and then makes His verses firm. It does not mention Surat al-Najm, al-Lat, al-Uzza, Manat, or the alleged sentence. It does not say that words of shirk became part of the final Quran, and it cannot independently authenticate reports whose chains are disputed. Nor does it specify the exact manner in which Satan's casting occurred.

Other exegetes understood the verse according to the ordinary meaning of wishing or desiring, with Satan casting doubts or obstacles into what a messenger wished to accomplish. Therefore, if the recitation-based interpretation is selected mainly because of the disputed story, it cannot then be used as independent proof of that story. At most, on that interpretation, the verse teaches that Allah nullifies what Satan casts and establishes His revelation. It does not identify the alleged incident or prove that the Prophet (PBUH) recited idolatrous words as revelation.

The Quranic principle

The Muslim position does not depend on claiming that no temporary confusion could ever be alleged in a historical report. It rests on the Quran transmitted by tawatur, the absence of the alleged wording from the established Quranic readings, the principles of hadith criticism, and Allah's promise to preserve His revealed Reminder.

Indeed, it is We who sent down the Reminder, and indeed, We will surely preserve it.

Quran 15:9

And if he had attributed to Us some false sayings, We would certainly have seized him by the right hand, then severed his aorta, and none of you could have shielded him from Us.

Quran 69:44-47

This passage addresses the attribution of invented speech to Allah. It excludes the idea that the Prophet (PBUH) deliberately fabricated revelation and that such fabrication could remain genuine revelation. It does not, by itself, grade every later historical report or directly describe the alleged episode. It does, however, exclude the idea that an idol-praising statement became genuine revelation or remained part of the Quran.

The Quran also describes Allah making His Messenger (PBUH) firm when faced with pressure to alter the revelation:

And they were about to tempt you away from that which We revealed to you, that you would invent against Us something else; and then they would have taken you as a close friend. And if We had not made you firm, you might have inclined to them a little. Then We would have made you taste double in life and double after death; then you would not find for yourself against Us a helper.

Quran 17:73-75

These verses describe pressure to compromise and affirm that Allah made the Prophet (PBUH) firm. Their conditional wording does not report that he actually inclined to the polytheists or that compromised words became revelation.

Some classical Sunni scholars recognized naskh al-tilawa, the abrogation of recitation, as a possible category, although scholars differed over its details and applications. Even where that category is accepted, a claim that a passage was once part of the Quran and was then removed from recitation requires sound evidence. It cannot be inferred from reports whose chains and wording are themselves disputed. The possibility of abrogation does not rescue an unestablished narration.

Conclusion

The so-called "Satanic Verses" are not verses of the Quran. The famous claim that the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) recited praise of pagan idols appears in early reports, but those reports are disputed in their chains, wording, and interpretation. Some routes are mursal or disconnected, while other routes have been presented as connected but remain subject to criticism. It is therefore not accurate to say that every route is worthless, but neither is it accurate to present the story as an undisputed sahih hadith.

Some classical scholars considered that the reports might preserve a general historical basis, while others judged the story unestablished. That scholarly difference should be acknowledged. It does not authenticate the alleged sentence, make it part of the Quran, or undermine the Quran's transmission.

The soundly transmitted account is that the Prophet (PBUH) recited Surat al-Najm and that listeners prostrated. The surah itself rejects the idols, gives them no divine authority, and concludes with the command to prostrate to Allah. The responsible conclusion is therefore not that no early report exists, but that the exact allegation that the Prophet (PBUH) recited "satanic verses" is not established as Quran and cannot be presented as an undisputedly authentic prophetic report.

For more detail on the chains of transmission, the different versions of the story, and the Quranic evidence, see the related topic page on the Satanic Verses claim.