The objection is fair against a particular interpretation: Muhammad (PBUH) did not physically lead the Jews out of captivity or restore them to the land of Israel. But that fact does not disprove his prophethood; it shows that Muslims should not claim that a prophecy about a physical Jewish restoration was fulfilled by him.

The strongest form of the objection

A Christian may argue: if a biblical passage predicts a messenger who releases Israel from exile, then the proposed messenger should actually perform that historical act. Muhammad (PBUH) lived in Arabia, did not return the Jewish people to their land, and did not end a recognized Israelite captivity. Therefore, the argument continues, identifying him with that messenger seems to ignore the plain meaning of the prophecy.

That is a serious challenge to any Muslim interpretation that depends on this specific prediction. Muslims should not answer by pretending that Muhammad (PBUH) accomplished an event he did not accomplish.

What the Quran actually claims

The Quran does not present Muhammad (PBUH) as the leader of a political return of Israel from exile. Its claim is that he was the final messenger, sent to humanity, and that he brought religious and moral freedom from false worship, injustice, and burdens imposed by religious corruption.

"Those who follow the Messenger, the unlettered Prophet, whom they find written in the Torah and the Gospel, who enjoins upon them what is right and forbids them what is wrong, makes lawful for them what is good, makes unlawful for them what is impure, and relieves them of their burdens and shackles that bound them."

Quran 7:157

In this verse, the "burdens and shackles" are presented in a moral and religious context. The verse does not say that Muhammad (PBUH) ended a geographical exile. Likewise, the Quran describes his mission as universal:

"We have not sent you except to all humanity, as a bearer of good news and a warner, but most people do not know."

Quran 34:28

What this objection does and does not establish

It establishes that Muhammad (PBUH) should not be identified by forcing him into a prophecy whose central fulfillment is the physical restoration of Israel. If that is the prophecy's clear subject, the Christian interpretation has the stronger claim regarding that passage.

It does not establish that Muhammad (PBUH) cannot be the prophet foretold elsewhere. Muslim arguments traditionally examine broader criteria: the prophet's message, character, universal mission, preservation of revelation, and whether the text's language genuinely points to him. Nor does the objection refute the Quran itself; it challenges one proposed proof from the Bible.

The plain answer, then, is: Muhammad (PBUH) ended no historical Jewish exile. Islam does not require him to have done so. The argument succeeds only if a Muslim claim depends on that particular physical fulfillment; it does not, by itself, disprove his prophethood.