The argument identifies a real development in the history of Quranic readings, but it misdescribes that development as a second canonization of the Quran. Ibn Mujahid did not create a new text; he organized and promoted a limited set of recognized reading traditions within a written and orally transmitted framework already established centuries earlier.
Why the objection sounds persuasive
The strongest form of the objection is this: if Uthman's standardization had settled the Quran in the seventh century, why were dozens of readers and many transmission paths still circulating in the ninth and tenth centuries? Why did Ibn Mujahid, working under Abbasid authority, select seven readers, while later scholars reduced each reader's tradition to two famous transmitters? This can look like political selection replacing reliable preservation.
That concern should not be dismissed. Early Muslim scholars did debate which readings could be attributed to the Prophet (PBUH), and not every reading found in later books was accepted as canonical. The history involves real scholarly judgment, not a single modern-style printing event.
What Uthman's standardization actually did
Uthman's project addressed a growing danger: Muslims in different regions were disputing recitations, while written copies used different dialectal and orthographic conventions. He commissioned copies based on the received consonantal script and sent them to major centers. This was standardization of the public written reference, not an attempt to record every authorized vocal or dialectal variation in one manuscript.
"If you differ with Zayd ibn Thabit on any part of the Quran, then write it in the dialect of Quraysh, for it was revealed in their tongue."
Sahih al-Bukhari
The early sources also report that the Prophet (PBUH) permitted more than one mode of recitation:
"The Quran was revealed to be recited in seven ahruf, so recite whichever of them is easy."
Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim
Classical scholars differed over the precise meaning of ahruf, but the reports plainly show that authorized recitation was not limited to one accent or one vocal form. The consonantal rasm constrained these readings; it did not need to display every detail of pronunciation.
What Ibn Mujahid did - and did not do
Ibn Mujahid's Kitab al-Sab'a selected seven especially prominent regional reading authorities. "Seven readings" was not identical to "the seven ahruf," nor did it mean that only seven Muslims had ever transmitted the Quran. His work was a classification of influential, defensible reading traditions. Other readings continued to be discussed, and later scholars recognized ten canonical readings, each with multiple transmission routes.
Likewise, naming two transmitters for each reader was a method of teaching and organizing the most famous routes. It did not erase every other chain, nor was popularity alone the scholarly test. Grammarians and recitation experts examined continuity of transmission, conformity with the Uthmanic rasm, and sound Arabic usage.
What the history establishes
This history shows that Muslims later regulated which recitations should be taught as canonical. It does not show that Ibn Mujahid reconstructed the Quran, that the state invented its wording, or that the text awaited tenth-century authorization. It confuses preservation of a text and its accepted recitational forms with the later cataloguing of those forms.
The Quran's preservation, in the classical account, rests on both written copies and continuous communal recitation. Ibn Mujahid's work reflects the management of that inherited tradition, not a second creation of the Quran.