The objection identifies a real hardship: a divorced woman may be poor, uneducated, and without dependable family support. Islamic law does not, however, treat post-divorce support as a single question; it distinguishes the former wife's rights during the waiting period, the husband's continuing duties toward children, and wider obligations of family and society.

Why the objection is serious

The strongest form of the argument is this: a woman may have devoted years to a marriage without gaining an income or property of her own. A one-time mahr may be modest or already spent, while iddat may end before she can become secure. If the former husband is able to support her, why should a formal deadline remove his responsibility? A rule that ignores poverty could appear harsh, especially where the woman has no parents, relatives, or public assistance.

That concern establishes a genuine case for compassionate policy and practical support. It does not, by itself, establish that the Quran requires a former husband to provide lifelong maintenance to every divorced wife. Moral sympathy and a specific legal obligation are related, but they are not identical.

What the Quran actually requires

During iddat, the divorced woman's position is not that of a stranger. In a revocable divorce, the marriage continues in important legal respects, and she is entitled to housing and maintenance. If she is pregnant, support continues until delivery. The Quran says:

"Lodge them where you dwell, according to your means, and do not harm them so as to make their stay unbearable. If they are pregnant, then spend on them until they deliver."

Quran 65:6

The Quran also commands a suitable parting gift:

"For divorced women is a provision according to what is acceptable - a duty upon the righteous."

Quran 2:241

Classical scholars differed over whether this mut'ah is obligatory in every divorce or especially where no mahr was fixed, but they agreed that divorce must not be used as an occasion for cruelty or financial abuse. The Quran further says that a childbearing mother may be paid for nursing, and that the father must provide reasonably for the child:

"Upon the father is their provision and clothing according to what is acceptable."

Quran 2:233

Why maintenance normally ends after iddat

After an irrevocable divorce and the end of iddat, the former spouses are no longer financially joined merely because they once married. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) ruled in the case of Fatimah bint Qays that a woman irrevocably divorced while not pregnant was not entitled to ordinary maintenance and lodging from that former husband. This is recorded in Sahih Muslim.

That limit does not abandon her. Her mahr, any applicable mut'ah, unpaid financial rights, and child-related support remain due. If she is poor, zakat, family assistance, charitable endowments, and responsible public welfare address that need. Her former husband may also give more voluntarily, and doing so can be an excellent act of kindness.

So the objection proves that communities must not leave vulnerable divorcees without support. It does not prove that Islamic law makes indefinite spousal maintenance a universal debt after divorce. The revealed framework combines enforceable marital rights with compassion, family responsibility, charity, and public justice.