The argument identifies a real difference between the earthly endings of Jesus and Muhammad (PBUH), but it turns that difference into a conclusion the Quran does not make. Jesus was raised alive and will return; Muhammad (PBUH) died, was buried, and entered barzakh - yet this does not mean that one prophet is more honored than the other, nor that Allah occupies a place above the heavens.

What the argument is rightly observing

The objection says that Allah specially rescued Jesus from his enemies and raised him "to Himself," whereas Muhammad (PBUH) was not removed from the world when his enemies opposed him. It therefore sees Jesus' ascension as evidence of a higher rank. It also assumes that Muhammad (PBUH) is simply dead in his grave and dependent on believers' prayers for peace.

The first point is true in part: Jesus was not killed by crucifixion, according to the Quran, and Allah raised him. Muhammad (PBUH), however, completed his earthly mission, died at his appointed time, and was buried in Madinah. Different endings can be part of different prophetic missions without implying different ranks.

"Raised to Myself" does not mean that Allah is a location

When Allah said, "O Jesus, indeed I will take you and raise you to Myself and purify you from those who disbelieve..."

Quran 3:55

Rather, Allah raised him to Himself. And ever is Allah Exalted in Might and Wise.

Quran 4:158

In these verses, "to Myself" expresses elevation to Allah's protection, honor, and nearness, while also affirming a real raising from the reach of Jesus' enemies. It does not mean that Allah is contained in a physical region, or that Jesus entered Allah's essence. Allah is exalted above creation and is not confined by space.

The verse is therefore a clear refutation of the claim that Jesus was defeated and killed by his opponents. It is not a ranking statement. The Quran itself says that Allah favored some messengers over others in particular ways; a special miracle or distinction does not automatically make one prophet superior in every respect.

Prophetic life in barzakh and the meaning of prayer

Islamic sources do not treat prophets as ordinary corpses whose existence has ended. They possess a special life in barzakh, though it is not the same as worldly life. The Prophet (PBUH) saw Musa praying in his grave:

I passed by Musa on the night of my journey, and he was standing and praying in his grave.

Sahih Muslim

So Muhammad's (PBUH) death does not mean humiliation or abandonment. The sending of blessings upon him is an act of obedience and honor for the believers, not evidence that he lacks honor or that Allah needs human assistance. Allah says:

Indeed, Allah and His angels send blessings upon the Prophet. O believers, ask blessings upon him and ask peace for him.

Quran 33:56

Jesus' ascension establishes his miraculous preservation and future return. It does not establish superiority over Muhammad (PBUH). The two prophets were given different signs and different endings, while both were honored servants and messengers of Allah.