The objection has real force against the idea that the Quran is meant to be an exhaustive encyclopedia of human history and science. But that is not what the Quran claims to be; its local language and examples do not show that its author was limited to local knowledge.

Why the objection seems persuasive

Human beings have existed for far longer than the civilizations named in the Quran. Most of its identifiable stories concern Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and peoples known in the Near Eastern world. It does not discuss China, the Americas, sub-Saharan societies in detail, or the full history of earlier human cultures. A critic therefore argues that the book reflects the information available to a seventh-century Arabian audience. If an omniscient author were speaking, why not provide a wider survey of humanity or disclose scientific facts unknown at the time?

That is a serious question, especially when particular Quranic statements are alleged to conflict with modern science. Those alleged conflicts must be examined individually; the mere absence of distant histories does not prove them.

The Quran does not present itself as a world encyclopedia

The Quran says that it was revealed in Arabic, to a particular people, through a particular messenger. Its purpose is guidance, warning, worship, and moral discernment, not the delivery of every fact that could be known. A teacher may address one class using examples familiar to them without being ignorant of everything outside the classroom.

We did not send any messenger except with the language of his people, so that he might make the message clear to them.

Quran 14:4

The stories are selected for their lessons, not because they form a complete chronology. The Quran itself says:

Indeed, in their stories is a lesson for those of understanding. This Quran was not invented, but a confirmation of what came before it, an explanation of all things, and guidance and mercy for a people who believe.

Quran 12:111

"An explanation of all things" means everything necessary for its guidance and religious purpose, not every subject in every possible sense. Classical commentators understood the Quran in this functional way, rather than as a catalogue of all nations, inventions, or natural laws.

Its horizon is not as narrow as claimed

The Quran refers to Egypt, Babylon, Rome, Persia, Saba, Midian, Thamud, and other peoples. More importantly, it explicitly denies that the named communities are the whole of humanity:

We certainly sent a messenger to every nation, saying, "Worship Allah and avoid false gods."

Quran 16:36

It also says that some messengers were not mentioned to Muhammad (PBUH):

We have sent messengers before you - some We have told you about and some We have not.

Quran 40:78

What the argument does and does not establish

The pattern of examples shows that revelation was communicated in a specific historical setting. It does not establish that the Quran's author possessed only that setting's knowledge. To make that conclusion, one must first prove that divine revelation would be obligated to include global history and modern science. Islam makes no such claim. The real debate therefore concerns the Quran's message, its language, its account of revelation, and any specific alleged error - not the absence of an encyclopedia.