Muslims pray five times because Allah commanded a pattern of worship that repeatedly turns the believer back to Him; not because Allah benefits from human prayer. The command establishes a disciplined form of devotion, while the concessions of Islamic law show that it is not meant to be an unbearable burden.

Why the objection is reasonable

The objection can be stated strongly: if Allah is self-sufficient, prayer adds nothing to Him. Repeated interruptions may seem inefficient for people with work, family responsibilities, illness, or demanding schedules. Why not perform all five prayers together at night, when the day is finished? That would preserve the total amount of worship while avoiding repeated disruption and, for some people, the difficulty of waking for dawn prayer.

This reasoning correctly recognizes that Allah does not need our worship. It also raises a real question about why obedience takes this particular form. But it assumes that the only purpose of prayer is to produce a certain total quantity of words and movements. Islamic worship is not merely a religious task to be completed; its timing is part of its meaning.

What the Quran says about prayer times

The Quran connects prayer to appointed times, rather than leaving its schedule to personal preference:

Indeed, prayer has been decreed upon the believers at specified times.

Quran 4:103

It also says:

Establish prayer at the decline of the sun until the darkness of night, and also the Quran of dawn. Indeed, the Quran of dawn is ever witnessed.

Quran 17:78

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) then taught the community the precise boundaries of those times. The five daily prayers were established through his consistent practice and instruction, and this has been the settled practice of Muslims from the earliest generation.

Prayer at dawn, midday, afternoon, sunset, and night places remembrance throughout the changing conditions of life. Work, meals, conversation, ambition, fatigue, and sleep do not become the believer's only horizon. The Quran describes this purpose plainly:

Establish prayer for My remembrance.

Quran 20:14

Why they are not normally combined

Combining all five prayers would preserve a number, but not the repeated remembrance intended by the command. A person can understand why a teacher assigns study at intervals, or why medicine is taken at prescribed times: the schedule itself serves a purpose. Likewise, prayer trains punctuality, humility, gratitude, and dependence on Allah across the day.

Islamic law also recognizes genuine difficulty. Prayers may be combined in certain circumstances, such as travel, and illness and other valid conditions bring further concessions. The Prophet (PBUH) said that the earth was made a place of prayer, and the law provides ways to pray according to one's ability.

Thus, the objection establishes that Allah has no need of prayer and that the schedule requires wisdom. It does not establish that the schedule is pointless or irrational. The Islamic answer is that Allah, who knows human nature, chose a repeated form of worship for our reform, while making room for hardship and legitimate need.