The Quran is not arranged strictly from longest chapter to shortest, and its order was not presented as a modern textbook's chronological table of contents. The arrangement serves a different purpose: a received form for recitation, worship, preservation, and reflection, while chronology and occasions of revelation are supplied through the Quran's own indications and the transmitted tradition.
The objection is stronger than a mere misunderstanding
A critic can reasonably ask why a late Medinan chapter such as al-Tawbah appears near the beginning, while many early Meccan chapters appear near the end. If a reader assumes that every passage should be understood in historical sequence, this order can seem disorienting. It can also seem to require outside reports about occasions of revelation before many verses become clear. By the standards of an ordinary human history or legal textbook, that would be a serious editorial weakness.
That criticism, however, depends on an assumption the Quran itself does not make. It is not a continuous biography, a chronological history, or a single argument proceeding from page one to its conclusion. It is a book of guidance that repeatedly addresses belief, worship, character, law, warning, consolation, and history. Its chapters often gather related material without following the timeline of revelation.
It is not simply a longest-to-shortest arrangement
The broad pattern is real, especially among the longer chapters, but it is only approximate. Some neighboring chapters differ greatly in length, and many shorter chapters do not follow a precise descending sequence. The order is therefore not adequately explained as careless sorting by the compilers.
Classical Muslim scholarship generally held that the placement of verses within chapters was fixed by the Prophet's instruction (PBUH), and the majority also regarded the order of the chapters as received, though scholars did discuss the evidence and details of that question. In either case, the early community was preserving a publicly recited text, not silently editing a manuscript according to personal preference.
Al-Tawbah shows why context matters, not that the text lacks it
Al-Tawbah begins with a public declaration concerning particular treaties and hostile groups in a defined period. Its opening is not a timeless command to attack everyone outside Islam. The same passage distinguishes treaty violations, grants a period of notice, and commands protection for a polytheist who seeks safety:
This is a declaration of immunity from Allah and His Messenger to those polytheists with whom you made treaties. So travel freely in the land for four months, but know that you cannot escape Allah.
Quran 9:1-2
The following verses must be read with their subjects, conditions, and the surrounding passages. This is why classical scholars used the Quran's cross-references, Arabic usage, prophetic explanation, occasions of revelation, and legal principles. Those sources do not repair a defective text; they describe how the text was meant to be read.
The arrangement does not establish that the Quran is chronologically ordered, nor does it guarantee that every passage is immediately self-explanatory to a first-time reader. It does establish a canonical order different from modern textbook conventions. Calling that incompetent editing only follows if chronological exposition was the Quran's intended genre - an assumption the Quran itself does not support.