The comparison is fair only if both claims are reduced to the bare statement, "I experienced a vision." Islam does not accept Muhammad's revelation on that basis alone; it considers the messenger, the message, the circumstances, and the public evidence surrounding it.
Why the comparison initially seems strong
A Christian may reasonably argue: John reports a heavenly vision in Revelation, while Muhammad (PBUH) reports receiving messages from the angel Gabriel. If private religious experience is rejected as evidence for John, why should Muhammad's experience be accepted? Unless there is a principled distinction, the criticism appears inconsistent.
This objection succeeds against a weak argument: "Muhammad said an angel came to him, therefore it must be true." Muslims are not required to accept that premise without examination. Nor does Islam teach that every person who claims a vision should be treated as a prophet.
The Quran does not present revelation as a bare vision
The Quran describes revelation as a message given by God, delivered through Gabriel, and confirmed by the truth of its content and the integrity of its messenger:
He does not speak from his own desire. It is only a revelation revealed.
Quran 53:3-4
That verse is a claim about prophetic speech, not an independent proof by itself. The evidence must therefore include the Quran's actual message: its uncompromising monotheism, moral demands, coherent worldview, and challenge to its first hearers. It also includes the Prophet's (PBUH) life before and after his claim. He was known among his people for honesty, endured persecution rather than gaining an easy advantage, and called people to worship God rather than himself.
The first revelation was not treated casually even by those closest to him. The Prophet (PBUH) returned shaken, and Khadijah comforted him by pointing to his character and conduct. The account is reported in the opening narration of Sahih al-Bukhari:
The angel came to him and said, "Read." He replied, "I cannot read."
Sahih al-Bukhari, Book of Revelation
Why John's vision is not automatically equivalent
Islam does not need to prove that every statement in Revelation is fabricated before declining to treat it as binding revelation. The Quran confirms that God revealed scripture to earlier prophets, but it also teaches that later communities could alter, conceal, or mix truth with human interpretation. A later text's claim to be divine is therefore not self-authenticating.
Revelation is also not judged by the title attached to a book. Its teachings must be consistent with the established message of the prophets: worship of the one God, moral responsibility, and accountability before Him. Where a text is anonymous or disputed in authorship, presents a private vision, and contains teachings that conflict with the Quran's clear account of God and prophethood, Islam has reason not to accept it as preserved revelation.
What this argument does and does not establish
The objection establishes that Muslims should not dismiss Christian testimony merely by calling it a vision. It does not establish that John and Muhammad have equal evidence. The Islamic case rests on a cumulative judgment about the Quran, Muhammad's (PBUH) character, his public mission, and the enduring content and transmission of his message. One may reject that case, but it cannot fairly be reduced to accepting one man's vision while rejecting another's.