One of the most important questions in the preservation of Islam is whether the earliest Muslims understood religious authority to exist only in the written Qur'an. The historical evidence points in another direction: from the beginning, Muslims treated the Prophet's explanations, judgments and practices as binding guidance alongside the Qur'an.
This argument should be stated carefully. It does not claim that every later report is automatically authentic, nor that every Islamic ruling can be proved merely by saying that early Muslims practised it. Rather, it asks what the earliest Muslim community believed the Prophet (PBUH) had authority to teach and command.
The argument from early practice
The argument is especially clear in the case of rajm, the punishment of stoning for a married person who commits adultery under the demanding evidentiary conditions of Islamic law. The Qur'an explicitly prescribes one hundred lashes for zina in Qur'an 24:2. It does not, in the form of the Qur'an recited today, explicitly mention stoning.
Yet the earliest Muslim authorities are reported to have recognised a distinction between the unmarried offender and the muhsan - broadly, a legally responsible person who had entered a valid marriage and had the opportunity for lawful marital relations. Reports describe the Prophet (PBUH) applying the punishment of stoning in particular cases, and later describe the Companions continuing to recognise it as a valid ruling.
The point made by proponents is therefore historical as much as legal: if the first generations applied a ruling not stated explicitly in the present Qur'an, this suggests that they did not regard the Qur'an as the sole source of binding religious guidance. They believed that the Prophet's authoritative Sunnah also conveyed law.
The report of Umar
A central piece of evidence is a report from Umar ibn al-Khattab, the second caliph. It is recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari, hadith 114, and is graded sahih by its inclusion in that collection. In a translation of its meaning, Umar says:
"Allah sent Muhammad (PBUH) with the truth and revealed the Book to him. Among what Allah revealed was the verse of stoning. We recited it, understood it and retained it. The Messenger of Allah (PBUH) stoned, and we stoned after him. I fear that, with the passage of time, someone may say, 'By Allah, we do not find stoning in the Book of Allah,' and so they may go astray by abandoning an obligation Allah revealed."
The report continues with Umar's concern that people might reject the punishment merely because they could not find its wording in the written Qur'an. It also mentions the severe evidentiary requirements: stoning was not to be imposed on the basis of suspicion or an unverified accusation.
For Sunni Muslims, this report is significant for several reasons. It presents the practice as known to the Prophet (PBUH), continued by the Companions and understood by Umar as a divine obligation. It also shows that the Companions were conscious of a distinction between what was recited as Qur'an and what remained binding as law. The report is not simply a later jurist's theory; it attributes this understanding to one of the earliest and most influential Muslim authorities.
How Sunni scholarship explains it
Classical Sunni scholars generally explained such evidence through the doctrine that revelation included both the Qur'an and prophetic guidance. The Qur'an itself commands believers to obey the Messenger (PBUH): "Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah" (4:80), and it instructs Muslims to accept his judgment (4:65). It also describes the Prophet's role as explaining revelation (16:44).
On this understanding, the Qur'an is not a self-contained list of every legal detail. It commands prayer but does not give the complete number of daily prayers, units, movements and timings in one passage. It commands zakah but does not state every applicable threshold and rate. Muslims learn these details through the Sunnah. A ruling such as rajm belongs to the same broader category: a prophetic legal explanation or judgment, preserved through reports and practice rather than through a verse in the present Qur'anic text.
Many classical scholars described the issue using the technical idea of abrogation of recitation while retaining the ruling: a wording was revealed and then no longer included in the Qur'an recited liturgically, while the legal ruling remained in force. This is the explanation reflected in much traditional Sunni legal and exegetical writing. It is important, however, to identify this as a classical theological explanation rather than present it as an uncontested conclusion accepted by every Muslim thinker.
The mainstream Sunni legal schools accepted rajm for the properly established case of adultery by a muhsan. Establishing zina required an exceptionally high standard, including the testimony of four reliable eyewitnesses to the act itself, or a valid confession. The law therefore did not treat rumour, pregnancy or mere accusation as sufficient proof. In practice, the evidentiary conditions were so stringent that the existence of the rule should not be confused with a routine policy of punishment.
The strongest objection
The strongest objection comes from those who hold that the Qur'an alone is binding. They may argue that Qur'an 24:2 clearly prescribes one hundred lashes for zina, without making an exception for married offenders. On this reading, reports of stoning either contradict the Qur'an or represent a later attempt to give authority to traditions that were collected in written form generations after the Prophet (PBUH).
This objection should not be dismissed as ignorance. It raises two serious questions. First, can a report said to preserve a non-recited revelation be verified independently of the later hadith collections? Second, if the Qur'an is described as complete and fully preserved, why would a legal punishment disappear from its recited text while remaining binding?
The Sunni answer is that the Qur'an itself gives the Messenger (PBUH) legislative and explanatory authority, so the question is not whether a ruling appears in the Qur'an, but whether it is reliably established as prophetic guidance. Sunni hadith scholarship did not regard every inherited report as equal. It assessed chains, transmitters, wording and corroboration. In this case, the evidence is not one isolated medieval statement: the reports of the Prophet's judgments, Umar's public position and the early legal understanding converge. That convergence is historical evidence that the earliest Muslim community distinguished between the Qur'an and the wider Sunnah.
Still, this answer does not eliminate every difficulty. The doctrine of a verse whose recitation was removed while its ruling remained is debated by some Muslim scholars, and Quran-only Muslims reject the underlying authority of hadith. Furthermore, a historical report can demonstrate what early Muslims believed without, by itself, proving that every detail of the belief originated with the Prophet (PBUH). The argument is therefore cumulative: it depends on the Qur'an's commands to obey the Messenger, the quality and convergence of hadith evidence, and the documented practice of the first generations.
What this establishes - and what it does not
The evidence strongly establishes that the earliest mainstream Muslim community did not operate with a Qur'an-only concept of religion. Early Muslims accepted binding rulings derived from the Prophet's teachings even when those rulings were not stated explicitly in the present Qur'an. The report in Sahih al-Bukhari 114 is particularly direct: Umar feared that people would reject a known obligation simply because its wording was not found in the Qur'an.
It also supports the Sunni claim that the Sunnah was not a late invention designed to supplement an originally self-sufficient Qur'anic religion. The Prophet's authority was treated as practical and legal from the earliest period. The Companions prayed, worshipped, judged disputes and applied law through both the Qur'an and the Prophet's guidance.
What it does not establish is that every hadith is authentic, that every later legal ruling is unquestionably prophetic, or that the historical case forces every reader to accept the classical explanation of the missing recitation. Nor does it by itself settle all moral and legal questions surrounding capital punishment. Those matters require separate discussion.
The modest but substantial conclusion is this: the earliest evidence is difficult to reconcile with the idea that Islam originally required adherence to the Qur'an alone. The first Muslim generations understood the Prophet (PBUH) to possess binding authority beyond the Qur'anic text, and they preserved that authority through teaching, practice and carefully transmitted reports. That is a significant historical sign in favour of the traditional Islamic understanding of revelation and preservation.