The claim is simple: Joshua (Yusha' ibn Nun) was granted an extraordinary sign - the sun was delayed until he had completed a military victory. Islamic tradition connects Joshua with the unnamed young companion of Moses in the Qur'anic account of the journey to the meeting place of the two seas. For some Muslims, this is evidence of a miracle granted to a prophet and of the reliability of the Prophet Muhammad's (PBUH) teaching.
That argument deserves to be examined carefully. It has a genuine foundation in authentic Sunni sources, but it establishes less - and more - than popular presentations sometimes suggest. It is not a Qur'anic scientific prediction, nor is it by itself a philosophical proof of Islam. It is an authentic report of a remarkable prophetic sign, which can contribute to a cumulative case for revelation.
The Qur'anic connection
The Qur'an does not name Joshua in the passage usually connected with this discussion. In Surat al-Kahf, Moses (PBUH) travels with a young companion during a journey to meet a servant of Allah who has been given special knowledge. When they reach a rock, the fish they had brought for food comes back to life and makes its way into the sea:
He said, "Do you remember when we took refuge at the rock? Indeed, I forgot the fish. And nothing made me forget to mention it except Satan. And it took its way into the sea amazingly." (Qur'an 18:63)
The Qur'an calls this companion a "young man" or "young servant," depending on the translation, but does not give his name. Muslim exegetical tradition commonly identifies him as Yusha' ibn Nun, known in English as Joshua. This identification is found in early Islamic explanations of the passage and in reports concerning the story of Moses. It should therefore be stated as a traditional identification, not as though the Qur'an itself explicitly names him.
The passage establishes that Moses travelled with a real companion and that the fish's revival was a sign leading them to the meeting with the righteous servant. It does not mention the later conquest, the sun, or the lengthening of the day. Those details come from hadith.
What the authentic hadith says
A report from Abu Hurayrah states that one of the prophets went on a military expedition. Before the battle, he gave instructions to his army, including that those who had married but had not yet consummated their marriages should not accompany him, and that those who had built houses but not completed them should not come. After victory, the prophet gathered the spoils, but the fire that normally consumed the spoils did not accept them. He then discovered that someone had taken from them unlawfully.
In the course of this account, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said that the sun was held back for that prophet until the victory had been completed. The version recorded by Sahih Muslim explicitly identifies him as Joshua ibn Nun and says that he was marching toward Bayt al-Maqdis (Jerusalem). Sahih al-Bukhari records the Abu Hurayrah account in closely related wording, but the explicit identification of Joshua should be attributed to the Muslim wording rather than casually presented as identical in both collections. Both versions are accepted as sahih in Sunni hadith criticism.
The sun was not held back for any human being except Joshua ibn Nun when he marched to Jerusalem.
English translations differ slightly: some say that the sun was "detained," "held back," or "stopped." The essential point is the same. The report presents the event as an exceptional divine intervention, granted to Joshua in connection with a military campaign.
Classical Sunni scholars generally understood this wording as a literal miracle, not merely a poetic description of a long day. The hadith does not specify a physical mechanism, however, so it should not be converted into a claim about the Earth's rotation or the motion of the sun. On that mainstream reading, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is reporting an event from the history of an earlier prophet, and it is not responsible to dismiss the story as an invented popular legend without engaging the hadith evidence.
The strongest case for the argument
The strongest version of the argument is not that the Qur'an contains a hidden astronomy lesson. It is this:
- The Qur'an refers to a journey involving Moses and his young companion.
- Islamic hadith identify that companion as Joshua.
- A rigorously authenticated report preserves a remarkable event concerning Joshua that was not narrated by the Qur'an itself.
- This is consistent with the Islamic understanding that Allah supported His prophets with signs, some of which were known through revelation even when they were not included in the Qur'an.
For a believer, the report fits a coherent prophetic worldview. Allah is not limited by the ordinary patterns of nature, and a miracle is precisely an exceptional event brought about by His command. The report also resembles, though it does not exactly reproduce, the Hebrew Bible's account in Joshua 10:12-14: there the sun is said to stand still over Gibeon and the moon over the Valley of Aijalon, whereas the hadith speaks of Joshua marching to Bayt al-Maqdis (Jerusalem). Muslims may understand this resemblance as continuity with an earlier prophetic tradition, but it should not be presented as proof that the two accounts are verbatim identical. Its presence in a hadith attributed to Muhammad (PBUH) can therefore be seen by a believer as confirmation of an event from the history of an earlier prophet, although that conclusion depends on accepting the hadith's prophetic authority rather than on the biblical parallel alone.
This is a reasonable evidential consideration, especially when combined with other arguments for the Qur'an and the Prophethood of Muhammad (PBUH). But it should not be inflated into something it is not.
The strongest objection
The most serious objection is that the story was already known in the Hebrew Bible, particularly in Joshua 10:12-14. A sceptic may therefore argue that the Islamic report is simply a later adoption of an existing Jewish or Christian tradition. On this view, there is no need to invoke revelation: Muhammad's (PBUH) community could have inherited or encountered the story through the religious environment of late antiquity.
This objection is historically possible and should not be answered by claiming that the story was unknown before Islam. It was not. Nor should one claim that the hadith provides an independent scientific discovery. It does not. The biblical account predates Islam, and the resemblance between the accounts is obvious.
The Muslim reply is more modest. First, the existence of an earlier written version does not prove that the event did not happen. If the event was part of the history of an earlier prophet, an earlier scripture or community may well have preserved it. Second, the Islamic claim does not rest on the story's novelty. The relevant question is whether the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) truthfully received and conveyed knowledge about earlier revelation, not whether every detail he taught had never been heard by anyone before.
Third, the report is transmitted through an isnad from Abu Hurayrah and is recorded in Sahih Muslim, with a closely related version in Sahih al-Bukhari. In hadith methodology, this supports a sahih grading for the report; it is not independent archaeological confirmation of Joshua's campaign, nor does it by itself rule out the possibility that a report about an earlier event circulated in Jewish or Christian tradition. But it means that the report should be evaluated as a formally transmitted Islamic testimony, not casually labelled a fabrication.
What the report does and does not establish
The report does establish, within Sunni Islam, that the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) authentically taught that Allah held back the sun for Joshua. It also illustrates the Islamic belief that earlier prophets received extraordinary signs and that Allah can alter the usual course of events.
It does not establish that the Qur'an predicted the event. Qur'an 18:63 mentions the fish and the journey with Moses' companion, but says nothing about the sun being delayed. It does not establish that Joshua's identity in that verse is stated explicitly; that identification comes from Islamic tradition. And it does not constitute a modern scientific miracle. The hadith is a historical and theological report, not a description of the earth's rotation, solar motion, or a testable astronomical mechanism.
Nor does the report, standing alone, prove Islam in the same way that a deductive argument proves a conclusion. A sceptic can maintain that the hadith reflects an earlier Jewish tradition. The Muslim case must then rest on the wider evidence: the Qur'an's message and preservation, the character and mission of Muhammad (PBUH), the structure of Islamic revelation, and the cumulative force of its theological and historical claims.
A balanced conclusion
The sun being held back for Joshua is a genuine Islamic claim grounded in sahih hadith, and Sunni Muslims are entitled to accept it as a miracle. Its association with Quran 18:63 is a traditional identification found in classical tafsir, not a conclusion compelled by the verse itself: the Quran does not name Joshua or mention the prolonged day.
The honest conclusion is therefore measured. This report is evidence of what the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) taught about an earlier prophet, and it can support belief in revelation as part of a cumulative case. It is not a Qur'anic scientific prediction, not an undiscovered fact unknown before Islam, and not a standalone philosophical proof. Its force lies in the credibility of the prophetic message and in the coherent picture it forms with the rest of Islamic revelation.